Gil's Thrilling (And Filling) Blog

Follow the Culinary Ruminations of New Mexico's Sesquipedalian Sybarite. 837 Restaurant Reviews, More Than 6500 Visitor Comments…And Counting!

Olympia Cafe – Albuquerque, New Mexico

The Olympia Cafe on Central Avenue

For culinary diversity, it’s hard to beat the University of New Mexico (UNM) area in which restaurants with a broad socioeconomic appeal are congregated. Aside from academic enrichment, this area is nurturing a refreshing open-mindedness toward the cuisines of the world.  That seems to be a commonality in areas within easy walking distance of large urban universities.  Perhaps restaurateurs recognize that students are not only willing to open up their minds to new knowledge, but their wallets and their minds to new culinary experiences.

The UNM area inaugurated many of us from rural parts of the state to wonderful new taste sensations.  The heretofore enigmatic mysteries of the Orient unraveled themselves the first time we tasted the sweet and sour variations of Chinese food and braved cultural taboos to actually consume raw fish.  The first time we sampled real pizza, we cursed Chef Boyardee and Pizza Hut for deigning to call their tomato sauce slathered cardboard “pizza.”  We lost a bit of our naivete and innocence with each bite of each and every new culinary adventure we experienced.  Life for many of us would never be the same.

I dare say that for many UNM students, especially those from rural areas, their first tastes of Greek cuisine occurred at the Olympia Cafe on Central Avenue.  The Olympia Cafe is a venerable elder statesman among UNM area restaurants, launching in 1972.  That’s when Spiros and Marina Counelis began serving Greek cuisine directly across the street from New Mexico’s largest university.

Hummus plate with olives, pita bread and pepperonici

Nearly four decades later, Spiros and his restaurant are still going strong though he’s admittedly tried to retire.  About the closest he’s been able to do is close the restaurant for a month each summer so he can return to Greece.  The Olympia Cafe is open only Monday through Friday from 11AM through 10PM, an accommodating schedule for students and employees of nearby businesses, but those of us from the outskirts feel a bit left out because the Cafe isn’t open on weekends.

The unmistakable aromas of well-seasoned Greek cuisine wafts onto Central Avenue, offering a welcome respite from the choking haze of automobile emissions.  Step into the restaurant and the first thing you see is a counter in which you place your orders.  The specials of the day are scrawled on a slate board on a restaurant wall while the daily menu is situated just above the counter.  Framed reviews are prominently displayed on one wall, including a 1991 Albuquerque Journal article proclaiming the Olympia Cafe one of Albuquerque’s 12 best restaurants.

After the aromas, the next thing you’ll notice is the restaurant’s liveliness.  The Olympia Cafe is characteristic of some family owned and operated Greek restaurants where animated dialogue emanates from the busy kitchen.  It’s all part of the restaurant’s charm.  As for ambiance, some would say there isn’t any.  Others appreciate the Mediterranean blue touches on the walls an the stereotypical Greek art which tends to focus on Olympian deities.  Lighting is good and seating is austere.

The Olympia Platter is a veritable feast of deliciousness Greek style.

You won’t be seated long before your number is called and you can walk to the counter to pick up your order.  Portion sizes are prolific.  It may take two of you to carry back the serving trays and their bounteous loads.  That’s especially true if you order one of the restaurant’s terrific appetizers and a dessert, too.

Among the former, a very good option is the taramasalata, what some people call “poor man’s caviar.”  The menu describes it as “pink caviar” and indeed it does have a pinkish-orange hue. Taramasalata is made from the salted and cured roe of either carp or cod.   The roe is mixed with various ingredients including vinegar, olive oil and lemon juice.  Though somewhat salty and some would say an acquired taste, if you learn to like taramasalata, it’s hard not to order it when it’s on the menu.

The Olympia Cafe’s rendition is quite good.  It is served in a small serving dish circumnavigated by four triangular wedges of warm, homemade pita bread, Kalamata olives, pepperonici and two dolmathes (grapevine leaves stuffed with rice and herbs).  This is a classic Greek appetizer sure to please aficionados of one of civilization’s oldest cuisines.  The dolmathes are especially flavorful.  You can discern the hint of cinnamon and maybe allspice among the spices used in the rice stuffing.

The restaurant is renown for its pita bread.  It’s made in-house and is served warm.  It might be the best pita bread in town (not withstanding the fact that many restaurants offering pita get it from a distributor and don’t bake it in-house).  No matter what you order, always request pita on the side.

Gyros

The best way to maximize your experience and appreciation of Greek cuisine is by ordering one of the menu’s combination combos (there are three combo platters on the menu, including one vegetarian).  The most diverse of those combo platters is the Olympia combo, a combination platter of Moussaka, Pastichio, Gyros meat with tzatziki sauce and dolmathes.  A small Greek salad replete with feta cheese is also part of this platter.

Pastichio might be described as the Greek answer to lasagna.  It’s a baked macaroni casserole layered with ground beef and topped with cheese and a cream topping.  All too often this entree is surprisingly dry, sometimes the byproduct of over-heating. That’s not the case at Olympia where it is moist and delicious, even tasting made to order.

Another casserole dish on the Olympia combo is Moussaka, a baked eggplant and ground beef casserole also topped with a cream sauce.  Moussaka is a very common dish in the Mediterranean region, but it’s vastly different in every country in which it is served.  The Greek version is my favorite.  Made correctly, the filling has a smooth and rich consistency and the eggplant is baked to perfection (not an easy feat).  Undercooked eggplant may leave your mouth with an inky taste sensation that can last for hours.  At Olympia, the sole sensation you’ll experience is the desire for a second portion.

Perhaps the most popular entree at the Olympia Cafe as at other Greek restaurants are gyros, slices of beef and lamb broiled on a vertical split then wrapped in a pita with tomatoes, onions and tzatziki sauce.  The beef and lamb amalgam is moist, tender and very well seasoned, but what enlivens it with flavor is the tzatziki which is made of finely chopped cucumber and dill and mixed with natural yoghurt.  There’s a tinge of sweetness to the yoghurt along with the fresh, cool taste of the cucumber that goes very well with the meat.  If anything, we would have appreciated even more of the tzatziki.

Galatoboureko, baked custard between crisp filo topped with a light syrup

In its annual food and wine issue for 2013, Albuquerque The Magazine awarded the Olympia Cafe a hot plate award for its chicken souvlaki.  Hot plate awards are accorded annually to some of the city’s most delicious dishes as seen by the magazine’s editors and staff.  The magazine describe this dish as “fit for the gods.”

 If you have any room left over, dessert options abound.  My favorite Greek dessert even though I’m still not able to pronounce it is Galatoboureko, baked custard between crisp phyllo topped with a light honeyed syrup.  The custard is rich and delicious but not at all cloying.  Galatoboureko is a Cypriot delicacy and one of the best desserts anywhere.

If your own life broadening experiences have yet to include Greek cuisine, the Olympia Cafe is a great restaurant in which to experience one of the world’s first and most delicious cuisines.

Olympia Cafe
2210 Central Avenue, S.E.
Albuquerque, NM
(505) 166-5222
LATEST VISIT: 20 October 2008
# OF VISITS: 1
RATING: *
COST: $$
BEST BET: Olympia Combo, Gyros, Taramasalata, Galatoboureko

Olympia Cafe on Urbanspoon