Gil's Thrilling (And Filling) Blog

Follow the Culinary Ruminations of New Mexico's Sesquipedalian Sybarite. 793 Restaurant Reviews, More Than 5700 Visitor Comments…And Counting!

Magnolias – Charleston, South Carolina

Magnolias01

Magnolias on a rainy Charleston afternoon

Some four million visitors flock to Charleston, South Carolina every year.  Charleston is the beguiling Southern charmer, a siren which lures guests with its storied history, artistic communities, architectural styles (which range from antebellum to art-deco), pristine beaches (on ninety miles of coastline) and, of course, incomparable Lowcountry cuisine.  Known as the “Holy City” because of the prevalence of churches on the city skyline, the sub-sobriquet “foodies’ heaven” is fitting; however, as songster Steve Miller reminds us in his hit tune Jet Liner, “You know you got to go through hell before you get to heaven.”

A great number of Charleston’s very best restaurants are clustered around the historic district, an area several  times larger and much more crowded than the Santa Fe Plaza.  Getting there is akin to being on a parade route, one with dozens of stop lights.  Arriving is only half the challenge.  Finding an empty parking spot is comparable to finding a car with working eight-track player.  You’ll drive around in circles for a while before finally wandering further out.  When you finally locate that elusive parking spot, you now have to traipse that much further on uneven cobblestone walkways to the restaurant while heat and humidity (or often the case, rain) sap you of energy and enthusiasm.  A restaurant had better be good for what it puts diners through to get there.

Magnolias02

Sourdough bread with a whipped butter

Located in the very heart of the historic district and situated in the site of the original customs house, Magnolias is worth the frustration and the trek. Open since 1990, it is one of the South’s most revered destinations for upscale Southern cuisine, a culinary approach it calls “Uptown/Down South.”  Magnolias is credited widely with helping spur the creative use of fresh seasonal bounty that sparked a revolution in Lowcountry cuisine.  Roadfood founder Michael Stern says it best: “…this restaurant has set standards of classic down south food served with uptown panache.”

A classically elegant fine dining restaurant combining true Southern flair with Charleston charm, Magnolias lives up to its name.  Though too early in the year to imbibe the sweet fragrance of blossoming magnolias, I could still appreciate the glossy leaves someone else would have to rake when they fall.  Freshly cut magnolia branches in clear vases festoon the main dining room and large paintings of magnolias hang on the wall.  An elevated horseshoe-shaped bar with tall stools provides the best vantage point if you’re into people-watching.  The most obvious observation may be that everyone is dressed better than you are.  South Carolinians are remarkably fastidious and ridiculously thin considering almost everything they eat is made with cream and butter.  Hmm, can their svelte physiques possibly be attributed to walking long distances from parking spots to restaurants?

Magnolias03

Blue Crab Bisque
fresh chives

The nattily attired wait staff is professional and on-the-spot with recommendations based on your taste preferences.  While you’re contemplating the menu and the day’s specials, a small loaf of sourdough bread with  a housemade whipped butter arrive, nestled in a white linen napkin.  The sourdough is crusty on the outside and soft on the inside.  Because it’s such an excellent bread, it may be a challenge to save a slice or two for dredging up some of the wonderful sauces that will soon decorate your plates.

In that my stay in the Palmetto State was so relatively short (one week), I made it a point to consume as much blue crab bisque as possible. Yeah, that’s the reason.  It has nothing to do with the fact that blue crab is one of nature’s perfect foods (just ask Larry McGoldrick, the professor with the perspicacious palate). Magnolias version of blue crab bisque may be the best I’ve had.  It’s served steaming hot and has a rich creaminess redolent with delicious crab meat.  Larry will probably attribute their deliciousness to the fact that these blue crabs migrated from Maryland.

Magnolias04

Down South Egg Roll

Perhaps the most famous (featured even on Southwest Airlines Spirit magazine) appetizer on Magnolias menu is the Down South Egg Roll, a crispy egg roll engorged with spicy tasso (a smoked ham), minced chicken and collard greens served with a moderately piquant red pepper puree, spicy ground mustard and topped with a sweet peach chutney.   These egg rolls have replaced the fabulous duck egg rolls at Zinc Wine Bar & Bistro as my very favorite.  The key to maximizing their enjoyment is to ensure every sauce is represented on every bite though these egg rolls are fabulous even sans sauce.

Magnolias is open seven days a week and serves lunch every day but Sunday from 11:30AM to 3:45PM.  Brunch is served on Sundays.  There are significant commonalities between the lunch and dinner menus–not only in the starters, salads and soup menus, but even among the Down South Entrees.  This is a very welcome departure from fine-dining restaurants who demote lunch to overly expensive sandwiches.  One traditionally Southern entree which should be served for every meal (and even snacks) is fried chicken.  Magnolias is among the very best I’ve ever had, on par with Stroud’s in Kansas City.

Magnolias05

Buttermilk Fried Chicken Breast
cracked pepper biscuits, mashed potatoes, collard greens, creamed corn, sausage-herb gravy

To honor my Kim, I ordered her very favorite foods, all served on one entree.  Picture a cold December day as the Dallas Cowboys are squandering yet seemingly insurmountable lead to lose another game.  My solace is buttermilk fried chicken, mashed potatoes,  gravy, biscuits and creamed corn.  These comforting foods are all available in one plate at Magnolias.  The buttermilk fried chicken breast is absolute perfection, a large de-boned chicken breast marinated overnight in buttermilk then deep-fried to a golden hue.  The mashed potatoes are partially covered (not submerged as is my preference) with a sausage-herb gravy.  Two cracked pepper biscuits, creamed corn and collard greens round out this plate (and my belly).  This is comfort food at its very finest. 

Dessert (which I ordered only as a public service should you ever need to know what to have) is limited to six items plus a number of ice creams.  Being limited in number is certainly not synonymous with lacking in deliciousness.  The Southern Pecan Pie is fantastic courtesy of South Carolina grown pecans, a bourbon caramel sauce and a topping of vanilla bean ice cream.  As with most pecan pies, this one is almost preternaturally rich, but so addictive, you can’t stop eating it.

Magnolias07

Southern Pecan Pie

In 2010, Charleston was named America’s “Friendliest City” by Travel & Leisure Magazine Two years later, it garnered the magazine’s number one spot for “Fine Dining Restaurants.” Magnolias ranks with the very best restaurants in Charleston, serving memorable meals that beckon for a return visit someday soon.

MAGNOLIAS
185 East Bay Street
Charleston, South Carolina
(843) 577.7771
Web Site
LATEST VISIT: 15 April 2014
# OF VISITS: 1
RATING: 26
COST: $$$
BEST  BET: Blue Crab Bisque, Southern Pecan Pie, Buttermilk Fried Chicken Breast, Down South Egg Roll

Magnolias on Urbanspoon

The Lady & Son’s – Savannah, Georgia

Lady&Sons02

Lady & Sons celebrates the cooking of celebrity chef Paula Deen and her sons

When I told friends and family of my impending visit to Lady & Sons, the Savannah restaurant owned and operated by former Food Network celebrity chef Paula Deen and her scions Bobby and Jamie, I expected a barrage of well-intentioned criticism.  The most “innocent” criticism would have to do with “a cacophony of cackling” and a “chorus of “ya’all” coming from the kitchen.  At least one dissenter, I believed, would accuse me of naivete in thinking the celebrity chefs might actually be present, much less actually preparing my meal.  The most cutting criticism–the one I feared most–would be  an accusation that a visit would actually be abetting racism.

Thankfully everyone to whom I mentioned my visit realized that the nature of any restaurant visit I make is with the express purpose of seeking enjoyment in the dining experience.  As such, you won’t read any mean-spirited personal attacks on this blog besmirching the character of Ms. Deen, who until recent years was as beloved a culinary glitterati as you’d find on the fruited plain.  It would be so easy to pile on, but my stance in doing so has always been right out of John 8:7: “Let him who is without sin cast the first stone.”

Lady&Sons03

Dining room on the third floor of Lady & Sons

Social commentary aside, there is much to be admired about Paula Deen, a true American rags to riches story who surmounted panic attacks and chronic agoraphobia to found a culinary empire that has made her wealthy and famous.  Her catharsis came from her cooking, first with a home-based catering business called The Bag Lady then in January, 1996, with the launch of her own restaurant, The Lady and Sons, in downtown Savannah.  In 1999, USA Today awarded The Lady and Sons its “International Meal of the Year” award.  Her first cookbook soon followed and its success, in turn, led to her first appearance on the QVC shopping channel.  In 2002, she landed her very first Food Network show.

The Lady and Sons and its attached gift store occupy nearly an entire city block in a large, weathered, three-story plus basement, 200-year old brick building on Congress Street with 15,000 square feet of dining, full service bar and office space.   Diners queue up shortly before the restaurant opens. As with many “pilgrimage” restaurants, conversation among those in line centers around what part of the country we’re all from.  There were few, if any, locals in line.  When your name is called, you’re handed a plastic card indicating whether you’re eating on the first or third floor of the restaurant (the second floor and basement are used for banquets).

Lady&Sons04

Cheddar Biscuit and Hoe Cake

The third floor dining room is meticulous and laid out for optimized efficiency.  The ceiling is arrayed in exposed ductwork and ceiling fans, perhaps the restaurant’s sole attempt at modernity.  Walls are festooned in framed artwork with a country theme.   Whether by design or not, the cynosure of the dining room is the buffet from which fragrant steam emanates and Southern delicacies are displayed.  By my estimate, at least seventy-five percent of the diners made their way, often several times, to the steely trays holding fried chicken, mashed potatoes, collard greens and much more.  When you’re done with the savory portion of the buffet, you order a dessert from the menu.

Should you eschew the all-you-can-eat gurgitator’s fest, there are plenty of attractive options on the lunch and dinner menus.  In fact, none of the buffet items are duplicated on the menu.  As you’re perusing the menu, a server will deposit a Cheddar biscuit and a hoecake on a plate.  There are several condiments on your table, including syrup should you wish to treat your hoecake like a pancake.  If your tastes lean more toward the piquant, douse the hoecake in Paula Deen’s Tabasco-like hot sauce which is quite good.  The Cheddar biscuit needs nothing added thanks to butyraceous qualities that even prevent it from crumbling.

Lady&Sons05

Fried Green tomatoes

Credit author Fannie Flagg with popularizing fried tomatoes with her 1987 best selling comedy-drama Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe.  Fried green tomatoes were pretty much unheard of throughout much of the fruited plain save for the Deep South where they’re practically a religion.  The Lady and Sons have perfected this starter over the years, serving a plate with five lightly coated green tomatoes topped with a roasted red pepper sauce.  The red pepper sauce has a sweet-piquant kick that complements the acidity of the tomatoes perfectly.  A ramekin with a homemade sweet Vidalia onion relish is a flavor contrast to the tomatoes.

During a visit to Joe’s Pasta House in Rio Rancho earlier in the month, we were treated to a wonderful seafood bisque which transported me back to my youth in Massachusetts.  That bisque was so good, it prompted me to seek out its equal during my trip to South Carolina.  The blue crab bisque at The Lady and Sons is close.  As with all great bisques, it’s served with wisps of fragrant steam escaping upward, a preview of its flavor.  Heavy cream and sherry give the bisque its creaminess while an insane amount of blue crab meat gives it an incomparable flavor.

Lady&Sons06

Cup of crab stew

One of the more popular entrees, according to my server, is a fresh seafood platter offering your choice of shrimp, scallops or oysters, batter-fried or sauteed and served with coleslaw and your choice of sweet potato chips or jelly roll fries garnished with fried-collard greens.  The platter also includes ketchup, cocktail sauce and tartar sauce though you can also apply any of the condiments on your table (hint: that Paula Deen hot sauce is pretty good if you like cayenne.)

Only two things would have made the seafood platter better–doubling the amount of seafood on the plate and making it a true seafood platter by offering it with at least two, preferably three, seafood choices.  The seafood portion size certainly isn’t penurious, but it’s so wonderfully prepared, you’ll want even more.  One of the secrets to great oysters is breading them lightly and frying them to a light, golden sheen.  When you bite into them, you should be able to discern a slight crunch followed by the incomparable, sensuously gooey texture.  The best description of how they should taste I’ve read is, “they taste as if God prepared them.”  These qualities all define the fried oysters at Lady and Sons.

Lady&Sons07

Fried oysters, coleslaw, jelly roll fries, fried collard greens

Despite eight years of living in the Deep South (Mississippi), jelly roll fries were brand new to me.  They actually resemble fried green tomatoes in that they’re roundish in shape and have a fried golden hue.  They don’t taste like conventional French fries or even fried potatoes, but go very well with the cocktail sauce.  The coleslaw is made with fresh ingredients and very little salad cream.   Best of all, it’s more assertively flavored (thanks to bell pepper, onion, carrot, and parsley) than so many insipid coleslaws.

As in so many Southern restaurants, you won’t find a compendium-like list of desserts at The Lady and Sons.  In fact, there were only four choices, two–pecan pie and key lime pie–of which seem to be de rigueur at all Southern restaurants.  The key lime pie is very good!  It starts with a great foundation in which a Graham cracker crust is paired with slivered almonds, the latter a very pleasant surprise.  The pie filling is redolent with key lime juice, lime zest and sweetened condensed milk.  It’s not quite lip-pursing sour, but offers a discernible tanginess you’ll enjoy very much.

Lady&Sons08

Key Lime Pie (almond Graham cracker crust)

The American media seems bent on building up cultural icons only to tear them down at some later point.  Only the most resilient and contrite survive having their transgressions made public.  Americans are a forgiving people–perhaps because we have so much to forgive in ourselves–quick to embrace our fallen heroes. I’m pulling for Paula Deen to rebound and resume her place among the pantheon of great American chefs.

The Lady & Son’s
102 West Congress Street
Savannah, Georgia
(912) 233-2600
Web Site
LATEST VISIT: 14 April 2014
# OF VISITS: 1
RATING: 24
COST: $$
BEST BET: Fried Oysters, Key Lime Pie, Fried Green Tomatoes, Crab Stew, Cheddar Biscuit, Hoecake

The Lady & Sons on Urbanspoon

Poe’s Tavern – Sullivan Island, South Carolina

Poe01

Poe’s Tavern in Sullivan’s Island, South Carolina

Had Edgar Allan Poe, the legendary writer of tales of mystery and the macabre, been born in modern times, he would likely have been recruited by the notorious National Security Agency (NSA), not to spy on Americans, but to work in its cryptography department.  While Poe didn’t invent cryptography, he certainly popularized it in his short story The Gold Bug, the most popular and most widely read of Poe’s works during his lifetime.  In the story, he used a substitution cypher to reveal the location of treasure buried by the infamous pirate Captain Kidd, estimated by the narrator to be worth a million and a half dollars.

The setting of The Gold Bug is Sullivan’s Island, South Carolina where Poe had been stationed for thirteen months while serving in the Army.  Described as “a laid-back, sun-splashed playground for residents of the Lowcountry,” Sullivan’s Island had a significant impact on Poe’s life, providing the setting for at least three of his stories.  It’s only fitting therefor that Sullivan’s Island is home to a very popular eatery and imbibery named for the enigmatic writer.  

Poe02

One of the lively dining rooms at Poe’s Tavern

As you cross over the white picket fence onto the restaurant’s patio, look down and you’ll see an ornate gold bug inlaid onto the concrete preceding the steps into the restaurant.  Look to your left and you’ll espy a thin mesh resembling a spider’s web extending from the corner of the roof to the fence.  Everywhere you turn, you’re reminded that Poe’s Tavern was named for a one-time Sullivan’s Island resident.  Step into the tavern and the sullen, sunken eyes of the abstruse one gaze down upon you from dozens of caricatures and paintings.  In the restroom, walls are papered with Poe’s writings.

Perhaps indicative of my advancing geriatric progression (but more likely attributable to avaricious hunger after wandering around Fort Sumter), I didn’t immediately notice all the scantily clad feminine pulchritude on the premises.  Poe’s Tavern is a very popular hang-out for nubile young sun-worshippers and brutish troglodytes either ogling them lustily or attempting to win them over with such sophomoric displays of their “manhood”  as uttering obscenities and belching loudly.

Poe03

The grim, somber countenance of Edgar Allan Poe is everywhere

Youthful clientele aside, Poe’s Tavern is actually very highly regarded for its culinary fare.  In 2012, Southern Living magazine named Poe’s one of the best purveyors of great burgers in the Carolinas.  Not surprisingly, all burgers are named for the tales of Edgar Allan Poe.  You can, for example, order The Gold Bug, the Amontillado, the Pit & The Pendulum and the Tell Tale Heart.  All burgers are half-pound of certified Angus Chuck beef, ground in-house and cooked to order.  Best of all, they’re charbroiled which imparts a high quality flavor and texture.

Southern Living magazine recommended the Annabel Lee, a burger topped with a Charleston style crab cake and fresh vegetable Remoulade sauce.  This is a very audacious burger in that it forces two dissimilar elements–beef and crab–to coexist.  It’s been my experience that such forced relationships don’t often work well.  Past experiences be damned!  This is an outstanding burger.  It’s skyscraper tall with both the beef patty and the crab cake both being thick and tall.  You’ll either have to mash down on it or unhinge your jaw in order to take a bite; don’t dare eat the crab cake separately!  Both the beef and the crab cake are moist and delicious, as delicious a surf-and-turf combination as you’ll find anywhere.  Forget mustard, ketchup and mayo.  The vegetable Remoulade sauce is all you need.

Poe04

The Annabel Lee (Charleston style crab cake on top with fresh vegetable remoulade sauce) and marinated bacon-bleu cheese coleslaw

All burgers and sandwiches are served with your choice of hand-cut French fries, potato salad or marinated bacon-bleu cheese coleslaw.  Opt for the latter because everything goes better with bacon or bleu cheese.  Together they’re an unbeatable combination especially if salad cream is used only lightly. The coleslaw is fresh and crisp.

Edgar Allan Poe’s favorite food was reputed to be lasagna, but had he tried the burgers at the tavern named for him, it’s likely the Annabel Lee would surpass lasagna in his estimation.  It’s a memorable burger!

Poe’s Tavern
2210 Middle Street
Sullivan’s Island, South Carolina
(843) 883.0083
Web Site
LATEST VISIT: 13 April 2014
# OF VISITS: 1
RATING: 21
COST: $$
BEST BET: The Annabel Lee with Marinated Bacon-Bleu Cheese Coleslaw

Poe's Tavern on Urbanspoon