Gil's Thrilling (And Filling) Blog

Follow the Culinary Ruminations of New Mexico's Sesquipedalian Sybarite. 742 Restaurant Reviews, More Than 4000 Visitor Comments…And Counting!

Señor Dog – Albuquerque, New Mexico (CLOSED)

My friends and culinary colleages Señor Plata and Boomer in front of Señor Dog

H. K. Duff VIII:  Why not break your fast with our brand-new Isotope Dog Supreme?
[Homer sniffs the hot dog.]
Homer Simpson:  Oh, so hard to resist. Mesquite-grilled onions. Jalapeño relish. …
Wait a minute, those are Southwestern ingredients. …
Mango-lime salsa? That’s the kind of bold flavor they enjoy in … Albuquerque!
Lenny: He’s right.
Moe:  Yeah … and the wrapper says “Albuquerque Isotopes”!

Within three months after the Duke City’s Triple-A baseball team, the Albuquerque Isotopes, co-opted its team name from The Simpsons animated television series, it sold more merchandise than the city’s previous Triple-A team, the Albuquerque Dukes, had sold in any entire season.  That was even before a single game had even been played. In that magical, inaugural year of 2003, the team led all of minor league baseball in merchandising revenue.

Unfortunately, the Isotopes moniker wasn’t accompanied by the fictional Isotope Dog Supreme.  Who wouldn’t love a hot dog with mesquite-grilled onions, jalapeño relish and mango-lime salsa?  It certainly would be oh, so Albuquerque.  Alas, the  Isotopes Park concession menu doesn’t include a hot dog nearly as imaginative or, ostensibly, as delicious as the Isotope Dog Supreme.  A case could easily be made that there isn’t a hot dog that cleverly constructed in the entire Duke City.

A root beer shake, one of 32 shake flavors on the menu

My friend Paul “Boomer” Lilly would take a stance contrary to that contention. Paul has become perhaps the Duke City’s biggest fan of Tickles & Snooks’ “Junk Yard Dog,” a quarter-pound all-beef hot dog battered and deep-fried then topped with onions, mushrooms, bacon, pepper Jack cheese, sauerkraut and Cheddar cheese on a hoagie roll. If this behemoth on a bun was available for breakfast, Paul would be there to get his early morning picker-up.

We expected that when Paul’s birthday arrived, he would ask his friends, me among them, to celebrate his thirty-somethingth birthday with a Junk Yard Dog or ten. How the engineers among us would adorn the dog with candles would be our problem, not his. Instead Paul surprised us by asking for his birthday celebration to take place at a brand new restaurant, one to which his joyous surprise, I had not heard of, much less tried.

The Shakes Menu at Señor Dog

That new restaurant, Señor Dog, opened for business on November 16th (with a grand opening on December 9th), the day after Paul’s birthday. Not wanting to fight the maddening throngs which seem to congregate any time a new restaurant (particularly a chain) launches, we decided to wait two days before making our inaugural visit. It was a good decision. Though there was a long line of curiosity-seekers and hot dog aficionados placing their orders, the staff was quick and efficient.

Señor Dog is ensconced in the Ventana Square shopping center on Paradise Boulevard, almost as far west as you can go in Albuquerque before you run out of city.  The burgeoning  Ventana Ranch area  is in dire need of non-chain restaurants to sate the growing population so Señor Dog is Juan-on-the-spot.   The marquee on the restaurant’s frontage depicts a sombrero-sporting hot dog while the restaurant’s motto is “Chillin’ in the Heat,” which we hoped would portend piquant and potent New Mexico chile and not that inedible stuff Texans call chili.

Guacamole Dog (Guacamole, Pico de Gallo, Jalapeños)

Brightly-painted walls festooned with posters; high ceilings; a painted concrete floor and functional tables and chairs give the restaurant a modern, almost antiseptic, industrial look and feel so many strip mall restaurants have nowadays.  The menu over the counter lists fourteen different hot dogs, each available as a basket (with your choice of fries, onion rings or a combination of the two) or as a super basket (two dogs and your choice of fries, onion rings or a combination of the two) plus a medium drink.  The caveat on the super basket is that the hot dogs have to be two of the same kind.  You can also upgrade from a medium drink to a milk shake for a dollar.

The shake menu one-ups Baskin Robbins “31 flavors” slogan by offering up some 42 plus different flavors of shake: apricot, banana, black cherry, black raspberry, blackberry, black walnut, blueberry, bubblegum, butter pecan, butterscotch, cinnamon, cheesecake, chocolate, coconut, creme de menthe, English toffee, espresson, lemon, malt, mango, mocha, orange, peach, peanut butter, pear, piña colada, pineapple, pistachio nut, pumpkin, root beer, strawberry and tutti frutti.  These are thick shakes served cold, not some runny, room temperature fiasco.

Chili Dog with French Fries and Onion Rings

Save for sides and beverages, the menu is all about hot dogs.  There are no burgers or sandwiches on the menu, the type of specialization which usually bodes well.  Alas, the spelling on the menu “chili” seemed  to forebode disappointment.  To mitigate the potential disappointment and improve the odds that at least one hot dog might be good, my friends Boomer and Señor Plata all ordered the super basket and had each hot dog cut in half.  That way we could all sample a half of each type of hot dog.

We need not have worried in the least.  The hot dogs were quite good, not ordinary in the least.  First of, they’re deep-fried, starting off frozen before being immersed in the fryer.  Unlike the famous “Ripper” style hot dogs served in New Jersey, the deep-frying does not tear the dog’s skin.  The frying does impart a chewy exterior texture while retaining a soft, juicy interior with a nice garlicky flavor profile.  Except for the Polish dog and the corn dog, the hot dogs are all beef.  They’re thick and delicious dogs served on a conventional soft bun.

Reuben dog (1000 Island Dressing, Swiss Cheese, Kraut) with French fries and onion Rings

The Guacamole Dog (guacamole, pico de gallo, jalapeños) may be the closest hot dog on the menu to the Isotope Dog Supreme of Simpson’s fame.  It’s a hot dog whose aroma arrives at the table before it does.  The pico de gallo and jalapeño combination is especially olfactory-arousing combination that goes very well with the velvety smooth guacamole.  Coupled with the garlicky, deep-fried hot dog, it’s a nice adventure in flavor appreciation.

The Chili Dog (red or green chile and cheese) is not redolent with the offensive aroma and grainy beef composition of Texas chili.  This chili is good enough to be spelled chile.  It’s good enough, in fact, to be served on a bowl separately from the hot dog.  A friend of mine who’s in the process of putting the finishing touches on a cookbook calls it “New Mexican chile,” better than the chile served at some New Mexican restaurants.  Alas, the gloppy processed cheese topping is not only messy, it detracts from the flavor of the chili and the hot dog.  This type of cheese belongs on ballpark nachos, not on hot dogs.  Without it, I’d still be raving about this hot dog.  Thankfully, Señor Dog also offers shredded cheese, a great improvement over the gloppy processed cheese.

The Senor Dog with green chili, cheese and onions

The green chili on the Señor Dog (green chili, cheese and onions) is nearly as good, albeit not as piquant as the red chili.  The green chili is made with ground beef and has somewhat of a soupy consistency, but it’s a good green chili (again, good enough to be spelled “chile” and served in a bowl).  As with the aforementioned Chili Dog, the gloppy cheese does this hot dog a great disservice.  Evermore I’ll remember to ask that the cheese be omitted (or preferably, taken outside and buried).

The most prominent flavor on the Reuben Dog (1000 Island dressing, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut) is that of the sauerkraut, a lip-pursing, tangy variety with a nice flavor.  We didn’t discern much of the 1000 Island dressing’s influence nor that of the Swiss cheese, but did enjoy this hot dog nonetheless.

A Chicago Dog and a Bacon Dog

Señor Dog’s menu also includes a fire-eater’s challenge–a half-pound, foot-long hot dog called the “Volcano Dog” with “fire chii”, cheese and onions.  You can have this hot dog with regular chili, but then it wouldn’t be a challenge to eat.  Any diner intrepid to try the fire-eater’s challenge must agree to and sign a waiver of liability form.  Challengers must consume the entire Volcano Dog with fire chili and all its contents within ten minutes.  There won’t be any relief from the heat during or for five minutes after all Volcano Dog contents have been certified as consumed by the manager.  Winners will have their photos posted on the restaurant’s “Wall of Flame.” 

The ingredient which gives the chili its incendiary kick is the infamous Naga Jolokia, commonly known as the “Ghost Chili,” the most piquant pepper in the world.  On the Scoville Scale which rates the piquancy level of all peppers, the Ghost Chili pepper tops the scale at 850,000 to 1.3 million Scoville units.  As of August, 2011, only six photographs adorn the restaurant’s “Wall of Flame.”

Señor Dog's "Wall of Flame" honors intrepid diners who finish the Volcano Dog

As more restaurants like Señor Dog make their way out far west, my friend Paul, a resident of the area, will be there to alert me to them.  We won’t even wait until another colleague’s birthday to visit.

Señor Dog
6541 B Paradise Blvd NW
Albuquerque, New Mexico
LATEST VISIT: 8 August 2011
1st VISIT:  18 November 2010
# OF VISITS: 3
RATING: 17
COST: $ – $$
BEST BET: Guacamole Dog, Reuben Dog, Chili Dog, Bacon Dog, Chicago Dog

Señor Dog on Urbanspoon

El Guero Canelo – Tucson, Arizona

El Guero Canelo for the quintessential Tucson food, the Sonoran hot dog

El Guero Canelo for the best in the quintessential Tucson food, the Sonoran hot dog

If asked to participate in a word association exercise, any well-traveled foodie undergoing psychoanalysis would find it easy to name the first food that comes to mind when a city is mentioned: Philadelphia – the Philly cheesesteak sandwich; Boston – baked beans; Chicago – Italian beef sandwiches; San Francisco – sourdough bread; Milwaukee – butter burgers; San Antonio, New Mexico – green chile cheeseburgers.  You get the point.  Some foodies might not know that Philadelphia is the birthplace of liberty, but they know about Geno’s and Pat’s King of Steaks and their decades-long battle for Philly cheesesteak supremacy.

You might find it strange that seemingly pedestrian foods would be the defining cuisine of burgeoning cosmopolitan cities, historically significant metropolises and tiny hamlets in the desert, but it’s not solely foodies who associate foods with places. Anthropologist Maribel Alvarez of the University of Arizona says the “quintessential food of Tucson” is the Sonoran hot dog, explaining that instead of taking guests to high-end restaurants, locals will bring their out-of-towners to one of the city’s purveyors of Sonoran hot dogs.

Hot dogs, like baseball and barbecue, aren’t exclusively the domain of Americans any more.  In fact, they never were. Before you call that statement unpatriotic heresy, consider the evolution of the hot dog.  Two words synonymous with that American term–frankfurter and wiener–come from Frankfurt, Germany and Vienna, Austria respectively.  In Germany, pork sausages were served in buns similar to those used in hot dogs while Austrians preferred a sausage made of a pork and beef amalgam.

The colorful menu at El Guero Canelo has something for everyone

The colorful menu at El Guero Canelo has something for everyone

In her fabulous tome The Great American Hot Dog Book, my friend Becky Mercuri writes that many popular foods in Arizona reflect the cuisine of the neighboring Mexican state of Sonora.  Those influences go far and deep in Tucson where the Mexican food is quite dissimilar to the foods with which New Mexicans are intimately familiar.  Not even the humble hot dog escapes those far-reaching Sonoran influences.

The Hot Dog Book celebrates the tremendous diversity of hot dogs across the fruited plain, examining in loving tributes the many ways in which hot dogs are prepared across America.  Becky showcases the best and most popular hot dogs in every state, even including recipes you’ll want to replicate in your own kitchen.  It was only natural that she include as the Arizona selection, the Sonoran-style hot dogs served in such paragons of hot dog deliciousness as El Guero Canelo and BK Carne Asada and Hot Dogs.

Though true hot dog aficionados are well-acquainted with Sonoran-style hot dogs and the aforementioned purveyors non-pariel, in April, 2010, both attained a heretofore unparalleled national profile.  The April 6th episode of the Travel Channel’s Food Wars show pitted El Guero Canelo against BK Carne Asada and Hot Dogs in a delicious duel to determine the best Sonoran hot dogs in Tucson.  Later in the month, Saveur magazine profiled “Eat Street,” the nickname of Tucson’s 12th Avenue in which both are denizens.

Throngs of patrons frequent El Guero Canelo, more since a Food Wars episode aired in 2010

Throngs of patrons frequent El Guero Canelo, more since a Food Wars episode aired in 2010

More than one-hundred vendors ply the Sonoran-style hot dog trade in Tucson.  Known as “hotdogueros,” they offer a surprising number of inventive variations on the Sonoran hot dog.  Where none deviate is in wrapping bacon barbershop pole style around a wiener then griddling or grilling it until the bacon has practically caramelized into the wiener.  A phalanx of garnishes and toppings are then stuffed into a bolillo style Mexican bread that resembles a hot dog bun that hasn’t been completely split length-wise.

Perhaps it’s only appropriate that El Guero Canelo, a claimant to being the original purveyor of the Sonoran hot dog in Tucson, champions authenticity and tradition more than any competitor in town.  El Guero Canelo, which translates to “the cinnamon blonde” is the nickname of its founder and owner Daniel Conteras.  The Contreras family has about a century and a quarter’s worth of cumulative restaurant experience, starting their Tucson operation in a humble 6X8 taco stand.  Today the family operates two full-sized restaurants.

El Guero Canelo, the original Sonoran hot dog restaurant on the celebrated “Eat Street” is the most famous and popular.  Save for the indoor kitchen, the entire complex is situated in a well-shielded outdoor pavilion.  In the summer, cooling misters dispense a fine drizzle to provide respite from the scalding heat.  In the center of the pavilion is a condiment bar that, save for the sneeze guard and metalwork, features the three colors of the Mexican flag: green, white and red.   Seating is more functional than comfortable.

Two Sonoran Hot Dogs, one with beans and one without.

Two Sonoran Hot Dogs, one with beans and one without.

Hungry customers queue up in one of two lines to place their orders, a vast proportion of which are for Sonoran hot dogs.  Order numbers are called out both in English and Spanish  You probably have time to visit the condiment bar for sliced cucumbers, radishes, pico de gallo, grilled onions and more before your order is ready.  Dally too long at the condiment bar and you’re likely to hear a rather animated reminder that customers need to pay attention to the numbers on their order stubs.

There’s a reason El Guero Canelo serves more than 10,000 Sonoran hot dogs a week.  These hot dogs are mouth-watering–a thin dog gift-wrapped in bacon and nestled in a pillowy soft, slightly sweet bun where it shares room with pinto beans, grilled onions, chopped tomatoes, mayo and mustard then topped with a hint of jalapeño sauce.  The buns are imported from a bakery in Mexico which prepares them to the exacting specifications of the Contreras family.  You’ll be besotted at first bite–to the tune of at least two hot dogs per visit.

This hot dog is a wonderful study in contrasts: the sweetness of the bun and the smoky savoriness of the hot dog and bacon; the heat of the hot dog and the cool of the chopped tomato; the piquancy of the jalapeño sauce and the creaminess of the mayo.  Moreover, it’s a study in the appreciation of complex simplicity.  Being in close proximity to other diners, you’ll be privy to your neighbor’s swooning lustily at every bite.  This is truly an amazing hot dog!  During a week’s stay in Tucson, we visited El Guero Canelo three times and readers know I’m the least monogamous person in the world when it comes to repeat visits to restaurants.

Some of the fabulous complementary condiments at El Guero Canelo

Some of the fabulous complementary condiments at El Guero Canelo

You’ll want to wash down your meal with El Guero Canelo’s fabulous aguas frescas.  The jamaica (hibiscus), pina (pineapple) and tamarindo are refreshing and delicious though not homemade.

El Guero Canelo has been serving Tucson since 1993.  While that may not seem like a long time, it’s long enough for the restaurant to have established itself as a standard-setter for a cuisine that is beloved throughout the city.  It is a perennial winner of Tucson Weekly’s annual “best of” in the Sonoran hot dog category and now holder of Gil’s personal “best of” for any hot dog in America.

El Guero Canelo
5201 South 12th Avenue
Tucson, Arizona
(520) 295-9005
Web Site
1ST VISIT: 12 April 2010
LATEST VISIT: 16 April 2010
# OF VISITS: 3
RATING: 23
COST: $ – $$
BEST BET: Sonoran Hot Dogs, Aguas Frescas: Pina and Jamaica

El Guero Canelo on Urbanspoon

BK Carne Asada & Hot Dogs – Tucson, Arizona

BK Carne Asada & Hot Dogs for fabulous Sonoran style hot dogs

BK Carne Asada & Hot Dogs for fabulous Sonoran style hot dogs

Every region across the fruited plain seems to have its iconic foods–incomparable dishes that define the area because they’re prepared better in that region than anywhere else.  Though there may be many capable practitioners in the preparation of these beloved and celebrated regional favorites, invariably there are restaurants with legitimate claims to superiority–stand-outs which, by virtue of consistent excellence over time, have earned acclaim from savvy locals and pundits.

When these paragons of mastery in the iconic cuisine are in close proximity to one another, spirited disputes generally ensue among locals as to which restaurant’s rendition truly reigns above all others.  The City of Brotherly Love, for example, becomes a dysfunctional family when proponents of its eponymous Philly Cheesesteak sandwich get together to debate the supremacy of either Pat’s King of Steaks or Geno’s.   To a lesser and certainly more civil extent, New Mexicans will dispute who makes the better green chile cheeseburger–the venerable Owl Cafe or the relative upstart, Manny’s Buckhorn Tavern.

The premise of the Travel Channel’s Food Wars program is to settle rivalries among those most celebrated of local favorites, pitting “the nation’s most famous culinary rivals against one another for a final showdown, where a blind taste test will settle the debate:Who makes the Best Dish in Town.”  Food Wars debuted in 2010 to much acclaim.  The show is hosted by the effusive and entertaining Camille Ford, the Travel Channel’s answer to Rachael Ray, the kitchen diva on the Food Network.

The BK Mascot carved from wood

A wooden carving of the BK mascot

On April 6th, the Travel Channel’s Food Wars program visited Tucson to settle a long-standing dispute and determine, once and for all, which of its two most famous purveyors prepare the most celebrated and iconic food in the city, the Sonoran-style hot dog.  This food fracas pitted El Guero Canelo against BK Carne Asada & Hot Dogs.  The former is a claimant to being the original purveyor of the Sonoran hot dog in Tucson while the latter has innovated the concept with delicious variations on the traditional.

Both El Guero Canelo and BK are situated in Tucson’s famous “Eat Street” within a quarter-mile of one another on Twelfth Street.  You can literally cross the street and walk a couple of hundred yards from one to the other.  The Eat Street neighborhood and Tucson are divided  as to which is best.  Though both have earned “best Sonoran hot dog” honors from Tucson Weekly, in recent years El Guero Canelo, the elder statesman by two years, has dominated the award.

The Food Wars format calls for blind taste tests in which an odd number (five) of judges taste each of the fabled foods and votes on their favorite.  Two of the judges are “superfans,” one for each of the two restaurants competing.  Ostensibly these superfans are so loyal to and so intimately familiar with their favorite restaurant that they can easily recognize its product even when temporarily deprived of sight.  For the Tucson Food Wars, the judges were a restaurant critic for Tucson Weekly, an anchor from a local television station and a former NFL football player.

Visitors from all over America head to BK Carne Asada & Hot Dogs

The superfans were actually brothers, the younger so loyal to BK Carne Asada & Hot Dogs that he carries a picture of a Sonoran hot dog from his favorite hotdoguero (a term describing Sonoran hot dog vendors), but his wallet doesn’t include a picture of his girlfriend.  The older brother declared his unwavering loyalty to El Guero Canelo.  Neither conceded much merit in the other’s preference, both adamant that their favorite would prevail.

When the grill smoke cleared, the former NFL player and the television anchor declared their preference for BK Carne Asada & Hot Dogs while the restaurant critic for Tucson Weekly (the only female judge) preferred El Guero Canelo’s dog.  With the tally two to one in favor of BK’s, the most dramatic and surprising moment in the show’s young history occurred.  Both superfans preferred BK’s.  You can well imagine the older brother will never live it down that he couldn’t recognize his favorite Sonoran hot dog when blindfolded.

A number of rabid fans from both camps cheered on their favorite and appeared to have a great time watching the process.  The episode showcased the difference between the two Sonoran hot dogs.  El Guero Canelo prides itself on staying true to tradition while BK’s has taken liberties with the condiments.  The recipe for BK’s award winning Sonoran hot dog, by the way, can be found on my friend Becky Mercuri’s fabulous Great American Hot Dog Book.  Frankly I’m not sure that many people will be able to discern the difference between the Sonoran hot dogs at BK’s and El Guero Canelo.

A Sonoran Hot Dog with a grilled pepper

A Sonoran Hot Dog with a grilled pepper

The law of primacy (being first) in learning posits that information learned first creates such a strong, almost unshakable impression that it’s difficult to unlearn incorrect information.  I’ve long believed there’s a law of primacy in eating, too.  The first truly great pizza you ever had, for example, often sets the standard by which you’ll measure all other pizzas.  The very first Sonoran hot dog we had was at El Guero Canelo so it would be interesting to see how pervasive the law of primacy would be and whether or not my contention would hold true.

Similar to its neighbor, BK Carne Asada & Hot Dogs is tailored for alfresco dining, a semi open-air restaurant in which the dining room is a concrete slab covered by a canopy which provides shade to protect diners from the onslaught of Tucson’s scalding heat and monsoon showers.  An anthropomorphic smiling hot dog, the restaurant’s mascot “greets” you as you walk in.  The menu is strategically positioned directly above the order counter.  It’s a menu dominated by Mexican fast foods: tacos, caramelos (similar to quesadillas), tortas, burros and of course, the Sonoran hot dog.

The menu includes several variations on the simple taco: carne asada, pollo, pastor, frijole, cabeza, borrego, fish and taco.  As you place your order, take a gander at the kitchen where a number of industrious people are engaged in the behind the scenes action that often goes unappreciated: chopping meat, grating cheese, flipping tortillas on the comal, preparing salsa.  Place your order and in a manner of minutes you’ll be called to a stainless steel cart to pick up your hot dogs.

Carne Asada Tacos

A trio of Carne Asada Tacos

BK’s rendition of the Sonoran hot dog is, at first glance, a prototype of the standard.  Frankly by mere glance alone, we couldn’t tell the difference between BK’s and the hot dog at El Guero Canelo’s.  The difference is in the tasting.  Similar to El Guero Canelo’s rendition, BK’s doesn’t use a conventional split-top roll.  Instead, a bolillo-style Mexican bread roll seems almost hallowed out to serve as a repository for a treasure trove of ingredients: pinto beans topped by the grilled, bacon-wrapped dog then diced red onions, chopped tomatoes, salsa verde and finally an embellishment of mustard and mayonnaise decoratively criss-crossing atop it all.

BK’s Sonoran-style hot dog is fantastic!  Perhaps if it had been the first of its genre we had sampled, it might be the standard-setter by which we will forever judge Sonoran-style hot dogs, but the law of primacy prevailed.  Unlike the Food Wars judges, we preferred El Guero Canelo’s version of this Tucson favorite, but the margin of preference wasn’t so significant that we wouldn’t return to BK’s.  In the end, the two differentiating factors were the slightly better grilled flavor and just slightly less soggy (from steaming) but sweeter buns at El Guero Canelo.  Both rate among the very best hot dogs we’ve ever had anywhere.

Because carne asada precedes hot dogs on BK’s marquee, we had to try a trio of tacos engorged with carne asada.  The carne is sliced into smaller than bite-sized pieces and is nestled in warm corn tortillas.   Nary a hint of sinew or excess fat could be found on the carne asada, a very good sign.  These terrific tacos would be reason enough to visit BK’s.

BK’s serves more than 10,000 Sonoran-style hot dogs a week. You can count on contributing to that total with every visit.
BK Carne Asada & Hot Dogs
2680 North 1st Avenue
Tucson, Arizona
(520) 207-2254
Web Site
LATEST VISIT: 12 April 2010
# OF VISITS: 1
RATING: 22
COST: $ – $$
BEST BET: Sonoran Hot Dogs, Carne Asada Tacos, Aguas Frescas: Pina and Jamaica

BK's Carne Asada and Hot Dogs (Sunnyside) on Urbanspoon