Vintage 423 – Albuquerque, New Mexico

Vintage 423 in Albuquerque’s Northeast Heights

My friend Bill Resnik, a professional stand-up comedian for more than two decades, performs a bit in which he “translates” Spanish terms for linguistically challenged audiences.  “Paseo del Norte,” for example, translates to “Paseo of the Norte.” For Duke City residents, the “Northern Route” is no joke.  It’s the corridor from the Northeast Heights to Albuquerque’s burgeoning West side, ferrying nearly 100,000 vehicles a day.  Paseo del Norte is widely credited with the rapid development–from 30,000 residents in 1980 to more than 85,000 in 2006–of the city’s growth north of Interstate 40 and west of the Rio Grande.  What most city residents don’t realize is that the official Department of Transportation designation for the 25-mile passage is State Highway 423.

It makes sense therefore that a restaurant in which people connections are made daily would incorporate into its name the highway designation for the bridge (figuratively and literally) between Albuquerque’s residents.  Because of its extensive wine offerings, the word “Vintage” (as in the year or place in which wine of high quality was produce) also makes sense, ergo Vintage Four Twenty-Three, a sophisticated and trendy milieu unlike any in the Duke City.  Launched in January, 2012, Vintage has since been a source of mixed opinions with vocal supporters and detractors alike expressing themselves passionately, especially on Yelp.

Baby Wedge Salad

Vintage 423 is the brainchild of owners Jason Daskalos and Rudy Guzman. Daskalos, a well-known Duke City developer and entrepreneur has been racing competitively since 2006 when he earned Rookie of the Year accolades in the Viper Racing League.  His love of competitive racing is apparent throughout the restaurant in the form of thematic framed photographs depicting vintage race cars and motorcycles.  By now means, however, is Vintage 423 just another sports bar trying to be an upscale eatery.  Nor is it a high-end bar and grill (for one thing, there’s no grill on the premises).  In some ways, it defies categorization.

The exterior facade, a departure from the abobe-hued stereotype which dominates Duke City restaurant and residential architecture, belies a swanky interior unlike any in the city. An opulent cosmopolitan world of subdued lighting, black walls and dark woods provides a distinctly intimate ambiance coupled with a high energy, hip and happening atmosphere. From the minute you step in, you’ll get the feeling you’re no longer in Kansas. One of the first sights you’ll espy are mesmerizing rivulets of shimmering water cascading from the ceiling, a wall of wine bottles directly behind this lighted waterfall.

Vintage Spiced Roasted Prime Rib

Vintage 423 sports an even larger wine wall which separates the dining area from the bar and lounge, boasting the largest selection in Albuquerque with some 500 bottles. It’s the type of wine wall you might expect to find at a high-end restaurant in Las Vegas, Nevada or maybe South Beach, Florida. The serpentine blonde onyx bar is also backlit, not so dark that you can’t read the wine labels but dark enough to set a relaxed mood.  An outdoor patio replete with fireplace and fire pits is available for seasonal dining.

Vintage 423’s motto is “Local, Bold and Imaginative.” The highest quality ingredients are sourced to showcase simple, pure, local, and regional flavors in a made from scratch menu unrivaled in the Duke City. Steaks include USDA Prime cuts and are aged for maximum tenderness and flavor. That menu not only showcases steaks, chops and seafood (such as steamed mussels, sauteed scallops, salmon, seafood linguine), but a number of sandwiches and burgers. Conspicuous by its absence is chile and, for that matter, other New Mexican food favorites. For the most part, the menu is “American” in all its nuanced glory.

The Epic Burrito

Each prime aged steak and chop is prepared to order on an infrared broiler which seals in all the juices and flavor. The temperatures on this broiler reach 1,200 degrees Fahrenheit which means the heat intensity penetrates all exposed surfaces of the meat, creating a meaty “crust” while allowing the interior of the steak to remain moist and juicy. This broiling process, by the way, is the same one used at high-end, high-dollar steakhouses such as Ruth’s Chris. Thankfully you’ll won’t pay Ruth’s Cris prices for a very good steak.

12 July 2020:  More than eight years elapsed between our inaugural visit and our second.  That’s certainly not because we weren’t impressed.  We were definitely impressed.  What we didn’t experience during our first foray was that inexplicable feeling of homeyness, being made to feel welcome with the sense of warmth and comfort that puts us at ease and made us feel relaxed. These factors are every bit as important to us as a restaurant’s cuisine.  Service was fine and cordial, but we somehow felt out of place, like fish out of water.  We eventually figured out that dining al fresco is more our speed.

Tres Leches Cake

Our return visit took place on a balmy summer day with record-breaking temperatures threatening, making Vintage 423’s expansive patio a welcoming milieu for Sunday brunch.  The patio not only provides sun-shielding shade, but good spacing for tables to ensure social distancing.  There are only seven items available on the brunch menu, but you can also order lunch entrees, sandwiches, soup salad and appetizers.  Several items, among them a chilled seafood tower, are more than a bit intriguing, but when you’re in the mood for brunch, the brunch menu is where your eyes gravitate.

12 July 2020: Tempting as the appetizers may be, six salads say you’ll at least consider them as an introduction to your meal.  Each of the six is an exemplar of combining quality ingredients to optimize concordance in taste, texture and appearance.  Our choice was the baby wedge (cherry heirloom tomato, hot house cucumber, red onion, shredded carrots, crispy bacon bits, Maytag blue cheese and classic blue cheese dressing), a salad which itself has earned the distinction “vintage.”  The wedge salad dates back to 1916 when it appeared in a book titled Salads, Sandwiches & Chafing Dish Recipes” by Marion Harris Neil. 

Iceberg lettuce is a superb canvas for ingredients, all presented artistically and split for our convenience.  As an avowed aficionado of bleu and blue cheeses, I especially appreciate the generous portion of Maytag blue cheese, an outstanding blue cheese made from homogenized cow’s milk instead of the traditional sheep’s milk.  Maytag blue cheese has a intensely sharp, tangy flavor and a pungent odor with nice creaminess. It’s one of my favorites.  The plentiful crispy bacon bits are strewn about like umami shrapnel, irresistible to one and all.  Fresh, juicy heirloom cherry tomatoes provide a balance of acid and sweetness. 

12 July 2020: “Brutally honest” English restaurant critic Jay Rayner tells it like it is: “A well-done steak isn’t a food choice: it’s a crime.”  That may be especially true about prime rib, an extremely tender rib primal cut.  Any more than medium-rare and prime rib loses the tenderness for which it is cherished. Kudos to the Vintage 423 kitchen staff for being on their A-game and serving a perfectly pink, nicely marbled and thoroughly tender prime rib with a flavor-packed spiced seared crust.  This melt-in-your-mouth prime rib tastes just as amazing as it looks.  The Vintage spiced roasted prime rib is served with duck fat potatoes as well as ramekins of au jus and horseradish sauce.

It’s now time for a deeply personal, tell it to Oprah level shameful confession.  In my youth, I couldn’t eat prime rib unless it was slathered in enough horseradish to defoliate a jungle.  Luckily sense and better taste buds now prevail.  My preferences are for mild horseradish sauce that ameliorates, not obfuscates the delicate deliciousness of the beef.  That’s what Vintage 423’s horseradish sauce does.  Now, if you haven’t had duck fat potatoes, you’ve got to make a run for Vintage 423 where cubed papitas are the rage.  They’re seasoned in magic dust so expect to become addicted.

 12 July 2020: Damn restaurants which offer carne adovada burritos for brunch!  It pretty much ensures my adovada-adoring bride won’t order anything else.  Vintage 423’s brunch offering is called the Epic Burrito and it’s constructed with scrambled eggs, duck fat potatoes and  your choice of applewood smoked bacon, sausage, ham or carne adovada smothered in either tequila and Dos XX gravy, red chile, or green chile cheddar jack cheese.  Worse, my Kim took what could have been truly epic and stripped it to its bare essentials–carne adovada alone, no smothering of any kind.  It was boring, but delicious.

12 July 2020: Five desserts grace the Vintage 423 menu.  You can certainly never go wrong with Tres Leches Cake, the favorite of our sweet server who assured me I’d love it.  While moist and tender, it wasn’t oozing the three milks with which Mexican kitchens have been preparing this cake for generations.  Its saving grace was an espresso cream sauce topping rich with the flavor notes that make coffee my very favorite adult beverage. 

Since its launch almost a decade ago, Vintage 423 has been a polarizing presence in the Albuquerque dining scene. Among Yelpers, opinions are about as divided as those in politics.  It may not be for everyone, but Vintage 423 certainly won us over with a memorable brunch in a west-facing patio one blistering Sunday.  We’ll be back.

Vintage 423
8000 Paseo Del Norte, N.E., Suite A1
Albuquerque, New Mexico
(505) 821-1918
Web Site | Facebook Page
LATEST VISIT: 12 July 2020
1st VISIT: 14 April 2012
# OF VISITS: 2
RATING: 19
COST: $$$ – $$$$
BEST BET: Baby Wedge Salad, Vintage Spiced Roasted Prime Rib, The Epic Burrito, Tres Leches Cake

About Gil Garduno

Since 2008, the tagline on Gil’s Thrilling (And Filling) Blog has invited you to “Follow the Culinary Ruminations of New Mexico’s Sesquipedalian Sybarite.” To date, nearly 1 million visitors have trusted (or at least visited) my recommendations on nearly 1,100 restaurant reviews. Please take a few minutes to tell me what you think. Whether you agree or disagree with me, I'd love to hear about it.

View all posts by Gil Garduno →

15 Comments on “Vintage 423 – Albuquerque, New Mexico”

  1. My husband and I have been to Vintage several times, over the past couple years as we live in this area. Food is very inconsistent, in the restaurant and over priced. We are foodies and go to top places to dine, we’ve given the restaurant many chances. Now we just have apps at the bar which are actually very good and more consistent. Never see the owners, nor do they make it a point to walk around and talk to their customers, Erica, at the bar is the best, always pleasant and smiling, very professional., we go back because it’s convenient for a drink and some apps, & chat with Erica, but will not eat in the restaurant.

    1. Yo Linda….lest I missed reading Y’all here before, Welcome to Commenting.
      Sorry to read about 423’s dining room! What Apps do you 2 find particularly UP? E.g. how’s the Tempura Shrimp and Crab Cakes? Had the Bisque or French Onion?
      Noting “We are foodies and go to top places to dine…”: Hopefully, Y’all might share your FAV dish and overall feeling for a few of those venues?

  2. Are you guys kidding. This restaurant is great!!It’s haters like you that are never satisfied and make this world so much more difficult for successful business owners!!!

    1. Because someone’s opinion differs from yours doesn’t make that person a ‘hater’. They simply had a different experience than you. Typically someone responding to a review with the term haters makes me immediately suspicious that the one throwing haters around is a friend or family member of the restaurant owner/manager.

  3. This Place truly sucks – the service is way off combine with the food !!!
    Was not pleased with it at all. My wife and and I noticed the owner Jason Daskalos was flirting with any young lady that went in. What a cheese head!!

  4. I was researching this restaurant as a potential “date night” for my husband and I, and the mixed reviews on Google, Yelp, and Urbanspoon had me about convinced to give it a pass – but then when I saw the food pictures here, I knew it was a “no.” I don’t think the food has gotten any better since Andrea pointed out that it just looks “off” – big, clunky plates with weird mishmashes of ingredients. Massive portions that are a dead giveaway that cheap ingredients are being used. Food that’s supposed to look “hip” but is not. (P.S., the artistic scribbles across the plate using multiple sauces? That went out of fashion many, many years ago.) My husband and I have eaten at many top fine dining establishments (including 5 restaurants from the “best in the world” list published each year). We know fine dining, and that food ain’t it. And we don’t have enough money or time to waste on a place with the spotty food and sketchy service that Vintage 423 apparently has, given the variable internet reviews. I know this place is trying to be Vegas-style “fine dining,” in that case, it seems like the restaurant managers should actually go to Vegas, to some of the fine dining places there, and see how things are done. “It’s fancy for Albuquerque” isn’t going to work any more. People have traveled and know how it’s done elsewhere. Not to mention, we have enough of restaurants who do “get it” and are doing things right – you can’t fool people with flashy décor, and make them forget terrible service and mediocre food. With Daskalos behind this, I am sure there will be money pumped in to keep the place alive awhile longer, which is a shame. Because any other non-rich-guy backed restaurant with the problems Vintage 423 has would be out of business by now.

    1. Michelle,

      Just to clarify, have you actually eaten in Vintage or is your negative review/opinion along with soon-to-be-gone wishes based solely on images? What’s the basis for the service criticism?

  5. I don’t mean to be a cynic, but it really does seem like some reps from Vintage 423 are publishing reviews on EVERY site using the phrases “great dining experience” and something like “sophisticated ambience”. A clue is that ambience is always spelled wrong. Maybe it’s just one enthusiastic patron, but it feels off to me. Thanks for all the reviews, Gil.

  6. What a great dining experience with a sophisticated ambiance. A youthful, New York style atmosphere. I had the filet and it was cooked to perfection. Will return again!

  7. Ugh. Am I just in a bad mood? Every single photo in your spread jumps out at me with something wrong and glaring, whether technique or ingredients or just common sense.

    50% on Urbanspoon so far…. they won’t last long unless something huge changes.

      1. It is the best and the most beautiful! Who designed the place? I’m looking for an interior decorator and love the interior of vintage. Please let me know 🙂 Thank you!

      2. Great food, great waitress, the young host Marley Rae had very poor customer service, my husband and I walked in, she asked rudely can I help you like we walked in the wrong place. Hope they train the hostess how to treat their customers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.