Frattellis – Rio Rancho, New Mexico

Fratelli's in Rio Rancho
Fratelli’s Pizza by the Slice or Whole Pies

In New York City, pizza by the slice is as ubiquitous as towering skyscrapers. Many of the city’s nearly 3,000 pizzerias serve pizza by the slice. Most have been doing so since the end of WWII when recently returned American veterans who served in Italy craved the sliced pizza they had enjoyed during their service. Heck, in the Big Apple, you can even find pizza by the slice proffered by sidewalk vendors. At about two bucks a slice, it’s usually pretty decent thin-sliced pizza blanketed with cheese.

A widespread presence doesn’t mean the practice is universally approved of. The other school of thought snubs its nose at the thought of serving by the slice, the triangle-shaped, tomato sauced pie Americans consume at the rate of 100 acres a day. Many traditionalists, particularly artisan Pizzaiolis with coal-burning oven pedigrees disdain the practice of pizza by the slice, scoffing that the practitioners of this sacrilege have reduced the art of pizza making to a fast-food assembly-line pretense.

While several pizzerias in the Albuquerque metropolitan area serve pizza by the slice, the lack of historical ties to the genesis of America’s pizza might be the reason you don’t hear the slice versus no slice debate rage on. On August 1st, 2006, Rio Rancho saw the launch of A&K Frattellis in which pizza by the slice isn’t an after-thought; it’s a primary draw. The A&K stood for Aaron and Kyle, the five- and three-year old scions of the restaurant’s owner at the time. Frattelli is Italian for “brother” so the name just makes sense. It also makes sense that a pizzeria in Rio Rancho would serve pizza by the slice; after all, isn’t Rio Rancho still called “Little New York” after all these years.

The western wall at Fratellis serves as an oversized menu
The western wall at Fratellis serves as an oversized menu

The A&K portion of the name was dropped when Fratellis was sold, but the formula–gigantic slices of delicious pizza delivered quickly to your table; efficient and friendly service; and reasonable prices–remains. It’s one of Rio Rancho’s most popular restaurants of any genre, one which transcends generations as evidenced by the number of happy families which make it their choice for pizza.

24-inch pizzas are the genesis for individual slices which you can order for a shade under three dollars (a two slice special and a drink goes for just over six dollars, including tax) and top with your favorite ingredients for a mere pittance. Each slice is huge, nearly as big as an entire pizza at pizzerias which specialize in thin-sliced gourmet pizza. It comes out of the oven hot enough to burn the roof of your mouth.

The menu also features five house pies including the Hawaiian Pie (Canadian bacon and pineapple), the New Mexican Pie (pepperoni and green chile) and the New York Pie (pepperoni, beef, sausage, onion, mushroom and black olive). Ask for it and free fresh garlic will be added to any pizza.

Up close and personal pie
Combination pizza from Fratelli’s

Several salads and a football-sized calzone are also available and there’s also stromboli, meatball hero, subs, bread sticks, cheese sticks, Italian desserts and more. The entire menu is available for carry-out or for dining-in. Delivery is also available on large orders.

The menu, by the way, is prominently displayed on the wall by the restaurant’s entrance as a green, white and red banner (the color of the Italian flag) hoisted by a mustachioed chef.

The pizza is usually terrific. The crust is thick enough to sustain ingredients which are generously piled on, but thin enough so that you can fold it laterally (another sign of New York style pizza). t has just a hint of char and its outside edges are heavily populated with the airy holes that seem to define good pizza. The sauce is applied lightly and is an excellent complement to all other ingredients.

A slice of Hawaiian pizza
A slice of Hawaiian pizza

If the New York Pie (not slice) is any indication, Frattellis crafts a fine pie (we normally order pizza by the slice). The sausage is replete with fennel, the pepperoni is tangy and nicely spiced, the mushrooms are deliciously fleshy fungi and the green chile (on my half of the pie) has a comal roasted taste without being particularly piquant.

A friend and colleague from New York consumed a slice and joked afterwards that the pizza contained triptophan, the sleep inducing chemical found in turkey. You can easily share a slice with a friend. Each slice is 12-inches at the top and tapers down to a perfectly pointed bottom. Two slices and you just might fall asleep, the contented sleep of someone who just had a great meal. Be forewarned, however, that sometimes individual slices tend to be hard-crusted, a sure sign they’ve been sitting under a heat lamp.

Fratelli’s joins several terrific pizzerias in the City of Vision. It will give the others a run for their money–any way you slice it!

Frattellis
3301 Southern Blvd
Rio Rancho, New Mexico
LATEST VISIT:
19 November 2007
# OF VISITS:
7
RATING:
19
COST:
$
BEST BET:
New York Pie, Pepperoni Slice, A’s Favorite

About Gil Garduno

Since 2008, the tagline on Gil’s Thrilling (And Filling) Blog has invited you to “Follow the Culinary Ruminations of New Mexico’s Sesquipedalian Sybarite.” To date, nearly 1 million visitors have trusted (or at least visited) my recommendations on nearly 1,100 restaurant reviews. Please take a few minutes to tell me what you think. Whether you agree or disagree with me, I'd love to hear about it.

View all posts by Gil Garduno →

17 Comments on “Frattellis – Rio Rancho, New Mexico”

  1. Sorry to say that it was very greasy when I went there. I brought back a piece for Sensei and just wasnt good. I usually write up on the 2nd time trying thinking perhaps it was a bad hair day for the restaurant owner but since it was asked here, thought best to reply…

  2. Anyone else with comments on the new Bambino’s? Some dude filled up their Urbanspoon page with negative comments so I’m not sure if that’s just him or if the pizza is really gone downhill.

    Still upset about what happened with Fratelli’s!!!

  3. The “For the Record” section in the 7/13/11 ABQ Journal noted that “the restaurant is closed for an undetermined length of time, owner John Margiotta said, due to litigation over payment of rent. He said Monday it may be closed for two to four weeks.”

    So there still may be an outside chance it could reopen.

    Journal article

  4. Tried to order Pizza from there on Sunday. No Answer. My wife drove by today and their was a sign on the door that said Out of Business. Sad to see it go. They had great pizza.

    1. I tried to visit Fratelli’s today and was greeted by the “Out of Business” sign, too. What’s most surprising about this closure is that only last month (June 24th), Andrea Lin, restaurant critic for the Albuquerque Journal gave Fratelli’s a glowing review, indicating Fratelli’s might be “the best I’ve had in quite a few years, possibly the best in the metro area.” This is another great loss to Rio Rancho area pizza aficionados.

  5. How could I be so lucky… I live right around the corner from Frattelli’s. I grew up in New Jersey and I can honestly say, this place is the best around. When I go for pizza… I want cheese, sauce and crust… none of that piled on BS like so many folks require. Maybe some mushrooms and/or pepperoni, but that’s it. The slices are huge… sprinkle a little crushed pepper, fold in half, and enter pizza heaven. I won’t go anywhere else in this town… fortunately, it’s so close that I don’t have to…

  6. BEST pizza EVER! We did without good pizza for a long time after the little place at Southern and Unser closed, (never can remember the name of it) but Fratelli’s is the only place we go for pizza now.

  7. Frattelli’s is one of our favorite Pizza shops, the New York.. oh yeah baby. That pizza rocks. Wouldn’t order it on as a slice though but any of the others work as a slice. It’s better than some of the better known pizza shops in New York City such as Ray’s or Joe’s on Soundview Ave in the Bronx (which unfortunately burned down) so it must not be the New York water as some people say unless Frattelli’s is shippin it in! One thing they need to do is offer Pesto… Yumm!

  8. Definately still open….this place is the home of great pizza at a great price. Check out the website. Giant slices and great service and smiles.
    A must try

  9. They closed briefly. But are open again with the same good pizza. The current owner worked for the previous owner, or that was what I understood. Great pizza! Have eaten there about 10 times since they opened.

    Rich

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.