Marcello’s Chophouse – Albuquerque, New Mexico (CLOSED)

Marcello's Chophouse in Albuquerque's Uptown
Marcello’s Chophouse in Albuquerque’s Uptown

Steak–even the word conjures stereotypes of power brokers in suits and ties. There’s just something about sizzling, flame-kissed beef that seems to appeal to the wheelers and dealers and movers and shakers among us. Steak may just be the ultimate power food!  That power is also wielded in the ultimate thumbing of the nose at vegetarians when carnivores emphasize that they didn’t claw their way to the top of the food ladder only to eat vegetables.

Vegetarians may retort that steak is antithetical to a healthful lifestyle. To carnivores, however, it’s not as important that steak may not be good for you as it is that steak is oh so good. Meat lovers emphasize that there is nothing like a perfectly prepared steak!

The Wine Lockers at Marcello's Chophouse
The Wine Lockers at Marcello’s Chophouse

As a 1995 episode of Seinfeld illustrated, steak is also not just a guy thing anymore. When Jerry took a blind date to the Old Homestead Steakhouse, he admitted “I’m not really that much of a meat eater” to which his date replied “You don’t eat meat? Are you one of those…” Questions about his masculinity persisted when she ordered a porterhouse medium rare and Jerry had a salad.

Some of our neighbors take their steak more seriously, by far, than we do. Witness the 1998 suit of Oprah Winfrey under Texas’s “False Disparagement of Perishable Food Products” statute.  America’s multiple-Emmy Award winning host of the highest rated talk show in television history was accused, in essence, of defaming a product fattened for slaughter in the feedlots outside of Amarillo, Texas then served up at the Big Texan Steak Ranch.

Sacrilege! Audrey Hepburn, a paragon of virtue, looks on innocently where only men should dare to tread

Alas, until recent years, the only potential steak related lawsuit contemplated in Albuquerque would have been by Duke City diners forced to choke down the artery-clogging, gristly, weakly flavored mediocrity that passes as steak at a plethora of chain steak restaurants.  Until the past decade or so, Albuquerque’s carnivores didn’t have many options when it came to velvety, buttery textured, nearly sweet, perfectly aged, optimally marbled steak.

Today, our fair city can boast of several steak houses that aren’t just good by Albuquerque standards. Some of the Duke City’s steakhouses would be competitive in larger markets where steak has been king for a long time. The November, 2006 launch of Marcello’s Chophouse may have signaled that this Duke City steakhouse is confidently throwing down the gauntlet and will vie for accolades not just with the locals, but with some of America’s best steak restaurants.

Lobster bisque
Lobster bisque

The appellation “Chophouse” in and of itself means more than just another steakhouse. In cities like Chicago, chophouses are where you find the best prepared slabs of USDA prime bone-in steaks, chops and seafood served in elegant milieus with attentive tableside service amidst classy decor. We’re talking selected, hand-cut on the premises prime steaks served charred and bursting with prime-aged flavor.

Marcello’s Chophouse is the fifth Albuquerque restaurant launched by Frank Marcello, a restaurant impresario responsible for bringing to the Duke City Copeland’s of New Orleans, Zea Rotisserie & Grill, Gruet Grille and the Gruet Steakhouse. Marcello’s Chophouse is the most lavish and upscale of his impressive array of restaurants. At nearly 7,000 square-feet, this swanky anchor tenant of the ABQ Uptown, has already earned several accolades, including an award of excellence from Wine Spectator.  Many Duke City oenophiles (wine aficionados) have even purchased their own wine lockers (pictured above) at Marcello’s. Every time they visit the restaurant, their favorite wines await them at optimum temperature.

Lobster Mac-n-Cheese - a blend of lobster cream, cheese & Maine lobster pieces in a cast iron skillet
Lobster Mac-n-Cheese – a blend of lobster cream, cheese & Maine lobster pieces in a cast iron skillet

The dinner menu is replete with chophouse steaks, bone-in specialties, chops, seafood and so much more. The lunch menu is abbreviated in both menu selections and prices. In fact, only two steaks grace the lunch menu, a seven-ounce petite filet mignon and a four-ounce steak Diane. Not everything on Marcello’s menu is exorbitantly priced. In fact, there are many items on the dinner menu within the easy reach of most price-conscious diners.

The lunch menu features many reasonably priced entrees that–although portioned somewhat smaller than dinner menu entrees–will let you feel like a million bucks without having to spend nearly that much. One dish available on both menus is the extraordinary lobster bisque, a soup which hearkens back to another Seinfeld episode in which Elaine recounts her date with a lawyer. “Yeah, I met this lawyer and we went to dinner. I had the lobster bisque, we went back to my place, yada, yada, yada, I never heard from him again.”Jerry rejoined with “but you yada yada’d over the best part” to which Elaine responded “No, I mentioned the bisque.”

Petite Filet Mignon
Petite Filet Mignon

You will never yada yada the lobster bisque at Marcello’s! It is simply one of the most sublime soups in Albuquerque. The soup, a rich and creamy bowl of deliciousness, circumnavigates a solitary reddish-hued lobster claw while other lobster bits are submerged beneath a steamy broth. The soup is ameliorated with brandied Crème fraîche, a high in fat content cream that improves the flavor of anything in which it is used. The lobster is sweet and delicious. Close your eyes and you might think you’re in America’s Northeast where this transcendent decapod swims from cold Atlantic waters practically onto your table.

If the lobster bisque doesn’t sate your lust for lobster, there’s always Marcello’s Lobster Mac-n-Cheese, a blend of lobster cream, cheese and Maine lobster pieces in a cast iron skillet.  This is a rich, adult macaroni and cheese but perhaps too heavily dusted with parmesan, leaving it a bit desiccated. Save for the lobster bits, it’s not quite as good as the Ultimate Mac & Cheese at Chef Jim White’s restaurant (now defunct). Mind you, it’s still very, very good.

Chilled “Really Big” Shrimp with green chile & red chile cocktail sauce

Marcello’s brines its steaks for 24 hours then flash fries them to order at very high temperatures, a technique mastered by few. Have the Lilliputian petite filet for lunch and you’ll be thinking about the “Chophouse Cut,” a 22-ounce bone-in rib eye cut from a slow-roasted prime rib, for dinner.  At three times the size of the petite filet, the bone-in rib eye cut will have to go a ways to match the flavor of its smaller brethren.

The petite filet mignon, a mere seven-ounces, takes a back seat to no steak. Order it prepared at medium and it will arrive to your exacting specifications. That means a crusty exterior redolent with herbs and spices and seared to perfection. It means a slightly pinkish and moist interior replete with flavor.  A great steak requires little or no help other than salt, pepper and garlic, but Marcello’s seasonings are extraordinarily flavorful. They seem to bring out the meat’s inherent flavors and heighten their impact on your taste buds.

Housemade pastrami on sourdough

The petite filet is served with a dinner salad crafted from a mix of greens and very lightly drizzled with a dressing that seems to heighten the greens’ native freshness. You might think a loaf of ciabbata bread might be more appropriate for an Italian restaurant, but somehow it works at Marcello’s. This crispy, fragrant herbaceous loaf is a welcome change from the de rigueur hard crusted breads at other high-end restaurants.

Marcello’s manages to incorporate New Mexico’s official state vegetable in a manner heretofore not seen at other restaurants throughout the Duke City.  I’ve long contended that chile can improve everything it touches (including some desserts) and Marcello’s substantiates this by offering green chile and red chile cocktail sauce with its chilled “Really Big Shrimp” appetizer.  Six jumbo shrimp (an oxymoron if there ever was one) looking more like miniature lobsters are offered with the chile offerings.  The red chile cocktail sauce is especially good with a combination of horseradish bite and red chile piquancy.  The shrimp are fresh with a nice snap to them and none of the mealiness you sometimes find in shrimp cocktails.

New Mexico Green Chile Cheeseburger with Chophouse Creamed Spinach

Not on Marcello’s daily menu, but perhaps it should be is a housemade pastrami sandwich.  A half-pound of nicely marbled, just smoky enough and perfectly seasoned pastrami is served on thick, lightly toasted sourdough.  The bread is slathered with a Dijonnaise (Dijon mustard blended with mayonnaise) sauce, lettuce and pickles.  Though rye and mustard is normally my preference, this is a surprisingly good sandwich courtesy of the melt-in-your-mouth pastrami sliced into thin ribbons of deliciousness.

One of the challenges in selecting New Mexico Green Chile Cheeseburger Trail worthy burgers is that many restaurants (even Lotaburger) offer green chile as a side and don’t necessarily have a green chile cheeseburger on their menus.  Marcello’s leaves nothing to chance, calling its offering the New Mexico Green Chile Cheeseburger.  It’s a beefy half-pound behemoth topped with New Mexico green chiles, caramelized onions and a three cheese blend (white Cheddar, Fontina, Monterey Jack).  The green chile is fairly mild, but the three chile blend is terrific.  Normally served with fries, ask for the Chophouse Creamed Spinach instead.  While some creamed spinach dishes have an acerbic aftertaste, this one is rather sweet, the result of a generous sprinkling of anisette and nutmeg.

Frank's Favorite "Bananas for Sundae"
Frank’s Favorite “Bananas for Sundae”

A stunning selection of desserts completes the package. Perhaps in tribute to his Louisiana heritage, Marcello adds his name to only one–Frank’s Favorite “Bananas for Sundae,” a take-off on Bananas Foster. Frank’s favorite just might become your favorite. This dessert features a vertically split banana caramelized with cajeta (a Mexican confection made from goat’s milk) surrounding scoops of chocolate, vanilla and dulce de leche ice creams which are topped with a fresh raspberry compote, chocolate ganache and housemade whipped cream. This is a “died and went to heaven” dessert–sinfully rich, unbelievably delicious and totally terrific. It’s no wonder it’s Frank’s favorite!

One caution about another of Marcello’s dessert offerings–if you’re going to order the chef’s selection of cheesecake, ask for spoons instead of forks because if you’re sharing this postprandial treat, you might stab your companion, so enthusiastic will you be for the next bite.  The cheesecake selections are seasonal.  Summer is apparently the season for milk chocolate cheesecake on a Graham cracker crust paired with white chocolate cheesecake on an Oreo crust drizzled with a dark chocolate ganache.  Shaped more like flan than cheesecake, this delicious duo will leave a memorable impression on your taste buds.

Chef’s Selection of Cheesecake: Milk Chocolate on Graham Cracker Crust and White Chocolate on Oreo Crust Drizzled with Chocolate Ganache.

There’s a strong chance Marcello’s Chophouse may become your favorite steakhouse in Albuquerque. It’s got the pedigree to be successful and the arsenal of deliciousness to win over even the most staunch of critics. It’s steak at its best and oh so much more.

Marcello’s Chophouse
2201 Q Street N.E., Suite 9B
Albuquerque, New Mexico

LATEST VISIT: 30 June 2012
1st VISIT: 11 April 2008
COST: $$$$
BEST BET: Lobster Mac-n-Cheese, Petite Filet Mignon, Lobster Bisque, New Mexico Green Chile Cheeseburger, Pastrami Sandwich, Chilled “Really Big Shrimp,” Chef’s Selection of Cheesecake, Frank’s Favorite Bananas for Sundae

Marcello's Chophouse Menu, Reviews, Photos, Location and Info - Zomato

6 thoughts on “Marcello’s Chophouse – Albuquerque, New Mexico (CLOSED)

  1. Some friends and I had lunch at Marcello’s on New Year’s eve. It was difficult to find; finally one friend called and asked for directions. We agreed we should have printed out a map. Though there is hardly any parking, the entire Uptown is made for drivers.

    We had made reservations and were seated immediately. The young man who was our waiter was quite nice and attentive. A nearby table spilled water during our stay (spilled it on themselves, not us) and the wait staff were right on it, as though it happened every day. Very efficient.

    I saw the lobster bisque on the menu and ordered it. Note: I have only ever before this had it at Tucano’s, and I have no idea if it’s even genuine there, but it usually tastes very good and I go back for seconds. What I was served at Marcellos had rubbery lobster (but maybe that’s natural for real lobster?) and the broth had an odd… vinegary? taste as well as maybe a little chile added. I finished it because it was expensive (I’d never ask for seconds of that).

    For entrees, my friends liked the macaroni and cheese and the steak (I think they ordered the Kobe beef, which was out of Idaho, not Japan). Had it been ribeye, I would have been tempted. Instead I ordered the fish and chips. The fish was two huge pieces of white fish in a thick coating. It was very hot (temperature) and difficult to cut. I took half home and it tasted fine the next day 😉 The tartar(?) sauce may have had chile in it; it seemed spicy and I didn’t particularly like it. I think some restaurants try to make simple things too complex to justify the pricde.

    We shared the chef’s selection of cheese cake (not chocolate that day, not enough chocolate on the menu), but it was tasty though I can’t recall the flavors — one of the two slices was orange and quite good. If there is a next time for me to visit, I’ll skip the appetizers and entrees and go right for the desserts!

  2. Good for lunch, but dinner has always been disappointing. Have eaten dinner there several times, business and personal, and for the most part have not enjoyed. At times the meal was ok and service was lacking, other times meal was horrible and service was lacking. For the price I would expect food and service to be impeccable; like fine steak houses across the country.
    Lunch on the other hand has always been a good experience. Try the Ahi Tuna sandwich or Bacon Cheeseburger also, both are reasonably priced and very good. As Gil says, must save room for the desserts; the Bananas for Sundae is addicting.

  3. We had lunch at Marcellos today. the food was good but the service sucked. Appetizers took forever and my husband’s soup arrived with his sandwich

  4. I have dined at the Chop House a few times now.
    I can only say that my meals have been hit and miss.
    This past Monday we helped a friend celebrate his birthday there and the results were much the same, some hits and some misses.
    I think they try to hard to be the quintessential clubby steak house.
    I ordered the veal chop and I must say it was terrific.
    It was terrific because I ordered it medium after the waiter described my version, slightly pink as medium well. Medium well?
    He described medium well as pink in the middle. That didn’t work out well for two of the other diners who were a bit disappointed in the medium well meat.
    My wife’s rib eye was much more “well” that medium and she had to send it back.
    She got her less well cooked rib eye about 20 minutes after that and felt the first one, although over cooked was a better piece of meat. In forty years it was the first time I recall my wife sending a steak back to the kitchen. What was very surprising is that the waiter made the suggestion that if she ordered it medium and it was too undercooked they could always send it back for more heat.
    Any more heat on the first steak would have made IDing it up to dental records.
    Some of the sides were not so hot especially the hard as marbles Brussel sprouts.
    Try the creamed spinach, a much better choice.
    And the NY Style Cheesecake had little in common with NY Style Cheesecake, period.
    The birthday celebrant was also unhappy with the piece of meat he ordered but chose to keep eating it.
    Fewer choices cooked with more precision and care could be one way to eliminate some of the misses.

  5. Second Christmas in row, and we go during the year as well. Chop House Rocks! Just take it slow and take two hours.

    Tonight: The 8 ounce American buffalo, in a crusted pepper reduction preparation, ancove? Finest STEAK of any kind I have had in my life. I am 52 and have been from the basement of the 4 Queens steakhouse in Vegas, to Jules Verne in Paris, and this simply was the finest piece of perfectly prepared red meat I have ever eaten.

    Wife had the Veal Oscar. Excellent. Son had the 22 ounce strip. Grew an inch. 3 sides, and hot cocoa cake. Sublime. Great Chateauneuf’depape by the GLASS, and a fine 9 dollar Port before dinner.

    I am hungry thinking about this dinner I had 3 hours ago.

    Merry Christmas


  6. Had dinner here last week and had the bone in ribeye. My wife had the surf and turf and we had Virginia blue point oysters for an appetizer. We had dinner at Donovans in Pheonix a couple of months ago. I had a bone in ribeye there as well and I have to say Marcellos blew it out of the water. It’s nice to know a steakhouse like this exists in Albuquerque. We need to try Vernons now to compare.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.