El Agave Restaurante and Tequileria – San Diego, California

El Agave Tequileria on the eastern fringes of Old Town San Diego

Tequila has long endured a legacy of scorn, derision and misinformation.  It’s  been a proving ground for manhood among frat boys downing shooters to show their mettle.  Urban myths and legends have long been believed of hallucinogenic worms at the bottom of the bottle.  Because of “ta-kill-ya” induced hangovers (usually the result of poor quality tequila), men with iron-cast constitutions have been known to swear off hard liquor.  With such a reputation, it’s no wonder tequila hasn’t been thought of as an adult beverage of choice for discerning drinkers.  

Times have changed.  In recent years, tequila has become a viable option for drinkers of sophisticated taste.  Credit this evolution of thinking to the Mexican government which–similar to what the French government did to bolster the image of Champagne and Cognac–has worked diligently to improve the image of its native beverage.  Stringent regulations have been instituted to ensure the authenticity and quality of tequila and it has been designated an “appellation of origin” which means true tequila can only be produced in a specific region of Mexico.  Premium tequilas, identified by the duration of the aging process, have entered the market, providing excellent choices for discerning drinkers.

More than 2000 decanters of tequila line the walls and ceiling at El Agave Tequileria

The spiritual Mecca to which all aficionados of premium tequila pilgrimage is El Agave Tequileria on the fringes of Old Town San Diego. El Agave is a veritable museum featuring a display of more than 2,000 tequila brands, easily the largest collection of tequila bottles in America.  El Agave has been named the country’s top spot for tequila by the likes of Playboy and Gourmet magazines.  Its own brand, El Agave Artesanal, has earned a number of awards.

The tequilas form the backdrop for a commodious dining room where diners can experience the authentic flavors of “nouveau” Mexican cuisine.  As you dine, a decanter or ten will catch your eye and you’ll stand up to investigate the bottled curiosity.  We found, for example, some eight decanters in the shape of or depicting Pancho Villa, an irony because Generalissimo Villa was a notorious teetotaler who had drunks in his army shot as cowards and traitors.   Hmmm, perhaps such an approach might help with New Mexico’s notorious DUI problem.

Three types of salsa and chips

El Agave is appropriately situated above the Old Town Liquor Store which (no coincidence here) offers some of the city’s best selections of tequila.  During our inaugural visit we had the tequila museum turned dining room to ourselves.  Every other diner opted for the patio which provides panoramic views of Old Town San Diego.  El Agave is the antithesis of so many touristy giant margarita and fish taco Mexican restaurants in the city.  It’s got an air of sophistication and class lacking in some of the Mexican “joints” in the frenetic Old Town area, many of whom seem to “mail it in” for the tourists.

Jim Millington, a long-time friend of this blog and one of its most prolific providers of valuable feedback, introduced us to El Agave.  He also provided savvy recommendations on what we should order.  Jim and I must be distantly related because the dish he recommended would probably have been the one I would have ordered.  Maybe there’s a little bit of gastronomic karma involved here.

Entremes Surtido: appetizer platter which includes guacamole, shrimp and crab empanadas, assorted sopecitos of cochinita; cuitlacoche and shrimp in chipotle; three beef taquitos; four mini quesadillas–two with mushrooms and two with poblano chile strips; four rolled taquitos stuffed with potatoes and homemade chorizo

As we perused the menu for an entree with which my Kim would fall madly in love, we enjoyed the complimentary (and wholly non-traditional) basket of chips and three salsas.  The salsas are made from green tomatillo, black beans and Guajillo chile respectively.  Surprisingly our favorite was the black bean salsa.  Though it had no discernible bite, it was redolent with flavor and served warm.  The Guajillo and tomato-based salsa was the most piquant of the three and the one which most resembled a New Mexican salsa.  All three salsas are quite good.

The Entremes (appetizer) Surtido (assortment) is the most costly starter on the menu, but it’s also the appetizer which will introduce you to the largest variety of Mexican starters.  Bear in mind that El Agave boasts of “nouveau” Mexican cuisine which means it doesn’t hold firmly to tradition, but rather expands upon it through the use of innovative ingredient combinations and culinary techniques.  This means even the entremeses aren’t the de rigueur no surprise appetizers found at too many Mexican restaurants.

Enchiladas de Pato: two shredded duck enchiladas bathed in sun-dried prune mole sauce and served with El Agave rice

The Entremes Surtido, a turkey platter sized offering, features a family-sized assortment.  At the center of the platter is a large dollop of lime-infused guacamole, among the most fresh and delicious we’ve had.  The shrimp and crab empanadas are also a winner with notes of briny freshness. Perhaps our favorite were the three sopecitos, three fried breads each topped with different ingredients in a chipotle sauce.  The cochinita and especially the cuitlacoche (corn smut) stand out.  Four quesadillas–two with mushrooms and two with poblano chile strips–were more “airy” than ingredient and flavor packed while four rolled taquitos accentuated the flavor melding of potatoes and homemade chorizo.  The danger with ordering a platter such as this one is you might not have much room left for your main entree and you’ll certainly want to enjoy every morsel of your main course.

That’s especially true if you order the enchiladas de pato two shredded duck enchiladas bathed in a sun-dried prune mole sauce.  It’s the dish Jim recommended.  Two large corn tortillas, redolent with the flavor of fresh corn, are engorged with shredded duck meat then topped with a spectacular mole.  To far too many diners in America, “mole” is just the four letters which complete the avocado dish of guacamole.  To discerning diners, mole is a sophisticated and complex sauce, the preparation of which is often laborious and unique.  The sun-dried prune mole sauce is made from dried chile peppers, ground nuts and spices, Mexican chocolate, shredded tortillas and a variety of other ingredients.  This mole is very rich, flavorful and complex with subtle notes of its constituents sneaking through. The duck (pato) meat is mostly lean with just a bit of fat for flavor. Only sharing this meal with Jim and his beloved child bride would have made it better.

Filete Al Tequila: Filet mignon in a tequila, red wine reduction sauce topped with cambray onions and mushrooms; served with mashed potatoes and vegetable medley

For my Kim whose preferences in exotic foods lean toward the safe and uninteresting, it took just a bit of Kissingeresque diplomacy to convince her the entree to order was the Filete Al Tequila, a filet mignon in a tequila and red wine reduction topped with cambray onions and mushrooms.  This dish is a stupendous success!  If you’re used to filet mignon being prefaced by “petite” on the menu, you’ll be pleased to see two stacked slabs of sumptuous, tender and lean beef, one atop the other.  The filet is nearly fork tender with nary a hint of fat.  With or without the tequila-red wine reduction sauce, the filet is extremely flavorful, as good a steak as we’ve had in recent travels.  The filet is served with mashed potatoes (wonderful for sopping up the sauce) and a vegetable medley, but not the dreaded succotash medley school children despise.  This medley featured zucchini and asparagus, both smoked and delicious.

Dessert isn’t quite an after-thought at El Agave, but with only four selections, it’s not the most interesting post-prandial menu either.  The pastel tres leches is a very good choice.  Rich, decadent and moist courtesy of the three milks-sweetened condensed milk, evaporated milk and heavy cream–that make up this cake, it is light in flavor, but not in calorie and fat content.  This tres leches cake is cut and served round with decorative raspberry and chocolate drizzles on the plate.

Pastel Tres Leches

Just as tequila has become a serious drinker’s adult beverage of choice, El Agave is where discerning diners go when they’re tired of the same old fish tacos, burritos, beans and cheesy glop and they want something sophisticated, interesting and delicious. This is as far a departure from the touristy Taco Bell type restaurants as you’ll find.  

El Agave Restaurante and Tequileria
2304 San Diego Avenue
San Diego (Old Town), California
(619) 220-0692
Web Site
LATEST VISIT: 2 July 2013
BEST BET: Enchiladas de Pato, Filete Al Tequila, Entremes Surtido, Salsa and Chips

El Agave on Urbanspoon

3 thoughts on “El Agave Restaurante and Tequileria – San Diego, California

  1. The day before the Pizzaria Mozza experience we had dinner at El Agave.
    I made do with Creamy yellow squash blossom sopa from Castilla, blended with Onion, leeks, and celeryfollowed by the Mole Negro From Oaxaca, with four different chilis: pasilla, mulato, ancho and chipotle, tortilla, deep fried banana, sesame seed, peanuts, almonds, walnuts, raisins, tomato, tomatillo, celery, cinnamon, oregano, served over pork.
    She being a dainty eater had Quesadillas del Pueblo 4 mini quesadillas, all stuffed with manchego cheese; one of those with mushrooms, one with roasted poblano peppers, one with shredded chicken with tomato sauce and diced vegetables, and the other one only cheese. Served with chipotle crème-fresh.
    We had nothing to complain about and left happy.

  2. You never quite know but I was almost certain you could not help but like El Agave.
    For the past few years we have shown up in San Diego for a week every February and have built a list of places we really like and also places we really dislike. I should say that I have. The Child Bride has an old saying, “Food is Food” unless a place really upsets her. With that attitude I find it hard to believe that we live in the same universe much less the same house.
    If you still have spare time I am fond of Cafe Chloe, 721 9th Ave, San Diego, a tiny French ALMOST, but not really, dive place on a very rough edge of the Gas Lamp.
    I have also found that I really dislike most of the restaurants in the Little Italy neighborhood even though many are very highly rated. Enoteca Style, 1445 India St San Diego, is a notable exception. It is nothing like the upscale Italian places you have visited in the past week, in fact it is barely a restaurant. It does however have great Paninis, starters, cheeses, etc. Some however hate the place.

    1. Jim, we could really share some war stories about our respective wives culinary leanings. My Kim’s ordering practices can best be described as safe and boring. Alas, it’s a practice she employs even when she orders for me as she did last year at the legendary La Super Rica Taqueria. We had carnitas tacos instead of the famous Super Rica Especial. Yesterday on our way to Phil’s BBQ, I talked up the tri-tip sandwich, easily one of the best barbecue sandwiches I’ve had (albeit many years ago). She ordered a pulled pork sandwich instead, probably because it sounded safer. I can’t complain much, however. In exchange for taking her to the Olive Garden once a year, I can pretty much pick where we eat the rest of the year. It’s a rather unfair exchange. I wouldn’t subject Kim Jong Un to the Olive Garden (or maybe I would).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.