Five Star Burgers – Albuquerque, New Mexico

Five Star Burger on Wyoming

On Friday, March 19th, 2010 and to surprisingly little fanfare, a locally owned and operated burger restaurant by the name of Five Star Burgers launched in Albuquerque’s North Towne Plaza at Academy and Wyoming. Its opening predated by about a week, the launch of a similarly named burger establishment, an east coast based interloper named Five Guys which has exploded across the country with nearly 600 locations in 39 states. The latter opening was greeted with ruffles and flourishes, pomp and circumstance and throngs of curiosity-seekers and “chain gangs.”

Despite the relative lack of hype and brouhaha, Five Star Burgers won’t play second-fiddle to any burger restaurant. The name on the marquee will tell you that. That name is bold and maybe more than a bit audacious; some might say it borders on braggadocio. Five-star, after all, is a term used to denote the highest quality, something that is incomparable and absolutely without peer. In a rating system of one to five stars, it signifies the pinnacle, the top, the very best. My friends in Taos tell me the name fits.

Even at 3PM, Five Star is One Crowded Place

Taos is where owner Bob Gontram founded his first of five planned Five Star Burgers restaurants. The historical “Soul of the Southwest” and Bohemian haven is a tough restaurant town. A burger restaurant would have to be pretty good to make it in Taos. With a pedigree that includes creating more than a hundred restaurants as both a franchisor and franchisee, Grantham has the experience and vision to succeed even in tough markets.

Discerning that trends are leaning ever more toward healthy dining, Gontram opted not to launch another copycat burger restaurant serving machine processed burgers from suspect feedlots. Instead, his Five Star Burgers menu features all natural, antibiotic free 100 percent Angus beef from Harris Ranch, world-famous producer of superb quality beef and exemplar of “ranch to the table” beef production. Five Star Burgers is trans-fat free and environmentally conscious; even its packaging is biodegradable, made from corn and recycled paper.

Chocolate-Chocolate Shake and Salted Caramel Shake

The name on the menu may say “burgers,” but burgers are not, as a hard and fast, intractable rule, synonymous with fast food. If anything, Gontram has simultaneously slowed down and upscaled the concept of fast food. He does more to defeat the stereotype of burgers being unhealthy and greasy than perhaps any other burger restaurant in Albuquerque. If the menu alone doesn’t tell you this is no run-of-the-mill burger joint, it will be very obvious this is no “gobble and go” fast-food emporium when you don’t see a drive-up window anywhere in sight. In fact, you’re more apt to saunter into the restaurant than to make a mad dash from your car. That’s the pace at which the restaurant operates.

When you walk in, you’ll be amiably greeted and escorted to your table where you’ll be presented a well-organized menu. Take in the swanky digs. The ambiance is elegant in a neo-modern way with ebony ceilings and stark tri-colored walls. Seating is utilitarian and comfortable and includes a bar complete with high-back stools from where you can order beer or wine An attentive wait staff will check up on you frequently, but not to the point where it becomes a nuisance. Your first visit should be for a burger.  Weather permitting, take a seat in the patio, a spacious Dude-friendly place to enjoy a great meal.

Fried green beans with green chile mayo

The beef is fresh ground daily and char-grilled to order with an intriguing selection of condiments to adorn each burger. Burgers are served on a toasted brioche bun from Fano Bread Bakery, an Albuquerque institution. Adkins devotees can opt instead for a 12-ounce Harris Ranch hamburger steak sans bun, char-grilled to order with Gorgonzola cream and caramelized onions. A char-grilled Asian glazed salmon with grilled vegetables is also available and you can also substitute an all natural chicken breast for any burger.

Standard burger offerings include the 5 Star Burger (Gorgonzola cheese and applewood smoked bacon), Old Timer (tomato, lettuce, onion, pickle, condiments), Taos Burger (crispy green chile, BBQ sauce and Cheddar) and the New Mexico favorite, a rather unique Green Chile Cheeseburger (green chile, pepper Jack cheese, green chile mayo).

Mixed cart of fries
Mixed cart of fries

On October 1st, 2014, the national newspaper USA Today published a compilation of America’s “great burger joints,” one in each state. The choice for New Mexico was the green chile cheeseburger from Five Star Burgers. According to USA Today, “When you talk burgers in New Mexico, you’re talking green chile cheeseburgers. What distinguishes 5 Star Burgers, with restaurants in Taos and Albuquerque, is quality. Served on a brioce bun from local Fano bakery, their all-natural, hormone-and antibiotic-free Black Angus beef is ground fresh daily and cooked to order. The 8-oz green chile cheeseburgers come in two varieties. Both are delicious.”

When USA Today proclaimed Five Star’s green chile cheeseburger as New Mexico’s best green chile cheeseburger, it wasn’t some nameless, faceless writer in New York City making that audacious claim. The burger was recommended by Sally Moore, author of Culinary New Mexico, “the ultimate food lover’s guide” and one of my most trusted sources for information on New Mexico’s specialty food stores, cooking classes, wineries, bakeries, tortilla makers, food festivals and restaurants. It would have been easy for Sally to recommend one of the “usual suspects,” but in recommending a burger proffered by a relative newcomer, she was as bold as the burger she recommended.

My Brother Mario’s Huge Hands Make The Green Chile Cheeseburger Look Small in Comparison

The menu also offers a number of specialty burgers and sandwiches: the freshly ground 5 Star Turkey Burger (sage, red onion, peach or cranberry chutney), Green Chile Chicken Cheeseburger (all natural chicken breast, green chile pepper Jack cheese, green chile mayo), Lamb Burger (tomato, lettuce, mayo), Portobello Burger (crispy green chile, roasted red pepper, grilled onions, Gorgonzola cream), Reuben Sandwich (corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, Thousand Island dressing on marbled rye), Coho Salmon (tomato, red onion, mayo on brioche roll) and Grilled Cheese (Cheddar, Swiss, Pepper Jack, tomato marmalade, applewood smoked bacon on sourdough).

This formidable line-up can be ameliorated by a number of flavorful toppings: aged Cheddar, American cheese, pepper jack, Swiss, Gorgonzola, smoked Provolone, avocado, roasted sweet pepper, crispy green chile, caramelized onions, wild mushrooms and crispy applewood bacon, all available for a dollar a piece. At Five Star Burgers, you truly can have your burger your way!

Lamb Burger

You can even eschew burgers and sandwiches altogether with Five Star Burger’s selection of salads: Shanghai Chicken Salad (Asian and field greens, almonds, green onions, water chestnuts, crispy rice noodles, sprouts, sesame seeds and a spicy peanut dressing), Caesar Salad (Romaine hearts, garlic croutons, shaved Parmesan cheese), BLT Salad (crisp lettuce and diced tomato, applewood smoked bacon, Provolone cheese and a spicy Rojo Ranch dressing) or you can have a side Caesar salad with your burger or sandwich if you desire.

Aside from the side Caesar salad, available extras include French fries, sweet potato fries, a mixed “cart” of fries, a half order of fries, coleslaw and green chile on any menu item. To wash it all down, you can opt for Pepsi products or fresh-squeezed lemonade, black leaf iced tea, raspberry iced tea, organic free trade coffee or shakes (chocolate, vanilla or strawberry) made with all-natural Breyer’s ice cream. You’ll want a mixed cart of fries with your burgers. A mix of standard French fries and sweet potato fries served on a fine mesh colander basket with butcher paper atop.  They go especially well with Five Star’s unique green chile mayo (all chile used by the restaurant is Hatch chile).

A1 Burger (8-ounce beef patty served with A1 sauce brushed on both sides, Cheddar cheese topped with fried onion straws on a toasted bun)

2 October 2010: Better yet, order the fried green bean appetizer served with green chile mayo. I first experienced fried green beans at a Vietnamese restaurant in Chandler, Arizona several years ago and have craved them since. Five Star has sated my cravings with some of the most tasty green beans in memory. Sheathed in a light batter, the beans have a snappy crunch while retaining the freshness and moistness of the green beans. Dip them into the accompanying green chile mayo for an even better adventure.

7 June 2014: The shakes are thick and delicious, made with real ice cream cold enough to give you “brain freeze” (an ice cream headache), but so good you won’t want to stop. Dreyer’s ice cream is renown for its slow-churned process which makes it more rich and creamy than other ice creams. The chocolate is chocolatey and velvety smooth, like a premium semi-frozen chocolate milk. Alas, the salted caramel is somewhat cloying with little of the salt influence discernible.

Five Star Burger with Gorgonzola Cheese, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Tomato Relish and Caramelized Onions
Five Star Burger with Gorgonzola Cheese, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Tomato Relish and Caramelized Onions

About a quarter century ago, my very favorite burger restaurant in Albuquerque was a tiny hovel on Cornell near the University of New Mexico. It was called the Sheepherder’s Cafe and the specialty of the house was a lamb burger with green chile. The closure of this unique student favorite was a heart-breaker. While a few other restaurants have offered a facsimile of the lamb burgers I so enjoyed, none approached the quality of the Sheepherder’s Cafe. That is, until Five Star Burgers.

27 October 2023: A mix-up in the kitchen resulted in a lamb burger with applewood smoked bacon, green chile, Gorgonzola and caramelized onions in addition to the standard tomato, lettuce and mayo. It’s the way I should order all my lamb burgers in the future (were it not for my “variety is the spice of life” philosophy. Five Star’s lamb is subtle and rich, not gamey in the least. Prepared at medium, its inside glowed with pink pulchritude. The applewood smoked bacon is chopped, not unlike bacon bits. The caramelized onions are a sweet contrast to the plucky Gorgonzola. This is a five-star burger in every regard.  My second instantiation of this magnificent burger was much simpler.  Tzatziki sauce (yogurt, cucumbers, garlic) was the sole condiment with lettuce, tomatoes and pickles on the side.  Five Star Burger’s pickles are among the very best in New Mexico.

Special of the Month for May, 2014: Pimento Cheese and Applewood Smoked Bacon Burger

21 March 2010: We adorned our Five Star burger, too, adding tomato relish and caramelized onions to the standard offerings of gorgonzola cheese and applewood smoked bacon. The contrast of sweet and savory toppings makes for an interesting flavor combination, a coalescence of deliciousness. The tomato relish is so good you might want to spoon it up.

27 October 2023: Five Star’s rendition of the green chile cheeseburger is made with Pepper Jack cheese, green chile mayo and green chile which is blanketed by the molten cheese. Alternatively you can ask for crispy fried green chile strips which former Albuquerque Journal critic Andrea Lin indicates “rival bacon in sheer deliciousness as a burger topping.” Either way, this is an excellent green chile cheeseburger. Grilled at medium it’s a juicy five-napkin affair. It’s not especially piquant even with the double-barrel approach of green chile and green chile mayo, but the green chile has a nice roasted flavor and it’s plentiful.

Grilled Cheese with a Beef Patty

2 October 2010: October, 2010’s burger of the month, hopefully a burger which will make Five Star’s menu, is yet another celebration of excellent beef ameliorated by complementary ingredients. The A1 Burger showcases an eight-ounce beef patty with A1 sauce brushed on both sides then topped with Cheddar cheese and fried onion straws on a toasted brioche bun. A national chain has a similar burger, but it’s not executed nearly as well. As with other Five Star burgers, this is a juicy and delicious burger, one for which a bib might be advisable.

7 June 2014: Five Star’s Burger of the Month for June, 2014 transported me back to South Carolina where my love of pimento cheese (a mix of grated cheddar, mayonnaise and diced pimiento peppers) was rekindled. Five Star paired pimento cheese with applewood smoked bacon to create one of the most intriguing and delicious burgers in town. Pimento cheese is a working person’s cheese, a cheese with personality courtesy of the beauteous pimento, a red cherry pepper with sweet flavor and very mild heat (100-500 Scoville units). Then, of course, there’s applewood smoked bacon at its salty, crispy and smoky best. Together they make an unbeatable combination.

Shanghai Chicken Salad

7 June 2014: Five Star has even managed to elevate the humble and oft boring grilled cheese sandwich into something spectacular. A triumvirate of cheese–Cheddar, Swiss, Provolone–paired with bacon and tomato marmalade on sourdough on its own makes for a three- or four-star sandwich. Add a Harris Beef Angus beef patty and you’ve got a somewhat subdued, but quite delicious version of a patty melt. With rye bread this sandwich would have the more assertive personality which would make this a true, even more memorable patty melt.

7 June 2014: Every once in a while, everyone should eschew French fries, onion rings and that ilk and opt instead for a salad. Salads go better with burgers than you might believe. Order a salad for two and the Five Star crew will split it for you. The Shanghai Chicken Salad (Asian and field greens, almonds, green onions, water chestnuts, crispy won ton noodles, sprouts, sesame seeds and a Thai peanut dressing is a very good bet, especially if you ask for extra Thai peanut dressing. The ingredients are fresh and crispy and the flavor profile is varied–sweet, savory and tangy.

Five Star Burgers is open 11AM to 9PM Sunday through Thursday and 11AM to 10PM Friday and Saturday. Try the other similarly named burger restaurant if you’re curious, but you’ll come back to Five Star Burgers. It’s more than a cut above. It’s the pinnacle, a true five-star burger restaurant.

Five Star Burgers
5901 Academy Road, N.E., Suite P3
Albuquerque, New Mexico
(505) 821-1909
Web Site | Facebook Page
LATEST VISIT: 27 October 2023
1st VISIT: 20 March 2010
COST: $$ – $$$
BEST BET: Chocolate Shake, Lamb Burger, Five Star Burger, Mixed Cart of Fries, Green Chile Cheeseburger, A1 Burger, Fried Green Beans, Shanghai Chicken Salad, Pimento Cheese & Bacon Burger, Grilled Cheese with Beef Patty

13 thoughts on “Five Star Burgers – Albuquerque, New Mexico

  1. Had lunch with my sister yesterday. We both order the Old Timer, she added cheese and I green chile. We had iced tea and she ordered fries and I the fried green beans with green chile mayo. I tried to persuade her not to order the fries as the last time I was there they were as limp as cooked linguine. She commented that they’d always been crisp and I said not any more. The burgers came and were cooked as ordered. Fried green beans were good, the fries were pale and limp and she ate a few and said No Bueno. So why have the fries gone down hill? My guess is a new chef that doesn’t know how to double fry potatoes.
    The fries were pale, not crispy on the outside or fluffy on the inside. Really bad, don’t order them. Will I go back, sure, for a burger and the fried green beans.

  2. Hey, Gil, great food pics. Never been to Five-Star, but as a Paleo-conscious eater I like the look of their slimmer top bun. Not the Derby-hat-thick usual one which restaurants serve to misdirect diners away from stingy ingredients.

  3. The meat, no matter what you order is fresh and prepared the way you ordered it. I like the fried green beans and the addictive fries with the green chile mayo, wish they had a jalapeno thousand island. The are consistent and I like a place I can count on for quality every time.

  4. We dropped by the 5-Star in Taos about 2 1/2-seconds (not exaggerating) before closing time and the place was still very full of customers. We had carefully picked the place by the fact that it appeared open unlike every place else. The manager put his keys back in his pocket and said “No Problem” which is a scary phrase in India but reassuring at 5-star. Since we had a late lunch we split the Green Chile Cheese Burger. I loved it. We will have to try the Albuquerque location now.

  5. After some good cheeseburgers at the Taos Five-Star, we made a trip to Five Star Burgers in Albuquerque. Included were family and relatives aged (literally) from 4 to 94. Everyone had something different, from Kid’s Cheeseburger to Bison Burger and a whole lot of burgers in between, some straight off the menu and others quite unique in components.

    Everyone loved their food. A couple people did say their meat was slightly overcooked, but they gave high marks, anyway. We liked the sides as well, especially the fried green beans (dipped in the green chile mayo!). We didn’t do any salads, but those who ordered shakes thought they were great. We arrived shortly before noon and got the last table, and the place was pretty much packed until we left a little after one o’clock. Our servers were efficient and courteous and responded quickly to our needs, but the orders did take some time to arrive.

    The place isn’t inexpensive, though, as the menu is a la carte, and a GCCB, fries and drink will run near $15. We saved a few bucks overall by sharing both the cheeseburgers and the sides, and Five-Star readily accommodated our needs. Everyone in our group thought the food was well worth the cost, and we all expect to return soon.

  6. My favorite thing at Five Star is their Rojo Ranch. Forget the Green Chile Mayo. Order your onion straws with the Rojo Ranch! You will not be sorry. Also, at Happy Hour (4-6 everyday), enjoy dirt-cheap fare. Good to eat and good for my wallet!

  7. excellent food and service. Went with friends for a birthday party. Great burgers all around, cooked perfectly to our differing specifications. Kelly, our waitress, was attentive and helpful with suggestions. Next visit I sat at bar and Christina was a nice conversatonalist as i drank local Marble beers on a pretty slow afternoon. I will be back as 5 star’s burgers and healthy eco-friendly concerns matter to me.

  8. Well we finally tried this place. I got the Green Chile Chicken Cheeseburger, a messy but yummy sandwich. Hubby tried the green chile burger. Also fries. It was all good. The problem was the slow service and untidy floors. I am sure we will try it again.

  9. I thought it was just okay. I miss the days of YesterDave’s so we thought we would try this place out; the fries were good but the burgers were okay. Our wait person delivered pretty good service but the table next to us complained about the lack of service.

  10. Really not that impressed. My burger was overcooked and dry. The fries were awful. The service was slow and sub-par. Also, pretty expensive. Won’t go back.

  11. My husband and recently ate at Five Star Burgers and we won’t be going back. The restaurant was nice and clean, and while we were undaunted by the prices, the lack of attention to detail was a real turn off. Let’s see: there were two of us and we each ordered a burger and they managed to get both orders WRONG! And we had to beg for an adjustment on the bill. The ingredients at Five Star are obviously great, but the front and back of the house have to work together to make a successful dining experience even if they are just burgers. So, over $30 for two (incorrectly prepared) burgers and fries … Why am I underwhelmed?

  12. Hi Brian, Actually this review was done on Five Star burgers. Five Guys and Five Star opened around the same time. Five Star is a local restaurant very different from Five Guys. Stop by and check it out, it is really great food. They are located at 5901 Wyoming NE 87109, next to Whole Foods and Borders.

  13. Tried my first Five Guys Burgers and Fries today. I have to admit that this is one of the best “fast” food burgers (bacon/cheese, “all the way”) that I have ever had — perhaps second only to a Double-Double “Animal Style” at In-N-Out. However the chaos, magnified by the fact that they have only been open for less than two weeks and the crappy weather that is springtime in Albuquerque, made the entire experience less than perfect. The space is loud (great classic rock), cramped and dirty. Those peanuts while you wait are a cute gimmick, but the ensuing mess hardly makes it worthwhile. How are they going to keep this place clean? I’ll go back, although I’ll be looking for a place to eat my to go order rather than dining in.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.