Lamy Station Cafe – Lamy, New Mexico (CLOSED)

The Lamy Station
The Lamy Station

History might best be defined as the interaction of people with one another and with their environments. Often those environments and the people indigenous to them are hardened by conditions and circumstances.

Fewer than 200 years ago, French and American traders endured tremendous hardship and peril on the route that came to be known as the Santa Fe Trail which connected New Mexico’s capital with the United States.

Large wagon trains ferried much coveted United States merchandise from Independence, Missouri to Santa Fe, earning enormous profits in the process. Trade was made easier in the 1880s with the introduction of the famous Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe (ATSF) railroad.

Interestingly (and despite its name), the ATSF never quite reached Santa Fe. Its tracks followed the Santa Fe Trail but because of the steep grades of the hills surrounding Santa Fe, it was left off the main line and the railroad was built instead through Lamy. Santa Fe was connected later by an eighteen-mile spur line from Lamy.

The dining car
The dining car

Lamy, named for Archbishop Jean-Baptiste Lamy, educator, missionary and the first archbishop of the American territorial period, is still very much a train town. The Amtrak system still runs trails daily in each direction (west to Los Angeles and east to Chicago) and both trains stop at Lamy.

The train station at Lamy remains much the same as it was when a dozen passenger trains a day ran along the ATSF’s main line. Parked to the immediate west of Lamy’s long-brick waiting platform and train station is a permanently stationed museum and functioning cafe appropriately named the Lamy Station Cafe.

The Cafe is situated in a restored Atlantic Coastline dining car built in 1949 and named the Talladaga.

The Talladaga was lovingly restored by Michael Gintert, a lifelong lover of all things train. Gintert spent more than a year and a half painstakingly restoring the railroad car. He launched his restaurant in November, 2006. It offers a stationary trip to yesterday with a decor that is true to its lineage.

A steaming hot bowl of Texas chili
A steaming hot bowl of Texas chili

Trace that lineage and you’ll find that the original American diner–streamlined, elongated and narrow in appearance with chrome and stainless steel appointments throughout–was never intended to remain stationary.

As opposed to horse-drawn wagons equipped to serve hot food, the original diners were actual dining cars on railways. When dining cars were no longer fit for service, they were often used as inexpensive diners at a (stationary) location near a train station or alongside a railroad at another location.

From a historical perspective, the Lamy Station Cafe holds true with to the diner tradition of serving pretty generic American food such as hamburgers, sandwiches and popular breakfast favorites such as French toast and several egg dishes. Traditional New Mexican entrees such as breakfast burritos and reputedly one of the best green chile stews anywhere are also available.

For the best of both lunch and breakfast, visit the Cafe on Sunday for brunch when an abbreviated eye-opening menu makes it worth getting up. The Cafe is open only for breakfast and lunch. Brunch hours are 10AM to 3PM.

Breakfast burrito served Christmas style
Breakfast burrito served Christmas style

If the aforementioned green chile stew isn’t available, maybe some good old-fashioned Texas chili will just have to do. While insulting all things Texan is one of the favorite pastimes of any native New Mexican, even us born-in-the-wool natives will appreciate the Cafe’s chili (despite the atrocious spelling of the word).

Unlike traditional Texas chili con carne, the Cafe’s version includes kidney beans. It also features hamburger meat, oregano, cumin, garlic and chili in a tomato soup thin chili with a dollop of sour cream. No self-respecting New Mexican would prefer Texas chili when the “real stuff”, our native chile, is available, but this will more than do in a pinch.

For real New Mexico chile, the Cafe’s breakfast burrito smothered in red and (or) green chile is a must have. The wafting aroma of the green chile as the waitress passes by your table with a breakfast burrito bound for another diner will make you appreciate the relatively cramped quarters in which you’re seated.

There is no aroma in the world quite as intoxicating as that of blistering, spitting green chile when it’s roasting on a hot comal. A friend of mine who’s a rather famous and prolific author tells me she’d like to wash her hair in that aroma. One whiff of the Lamy Station Cafe’s green chile and you’ll wish for the same thing. The Cafe’s green chile is procured from a local distributor committed to using the freshest and finest local ingredients.

The Conductor breakfast
The Conductor breakfast

The red chile comes from Socorro and it’s an excellent dark red chile, rich in flavor and redolent with a sweet, earthy fragrance that characterizes the best red chile in New Mexico. As captivating as is the aroma of the green chile, the red chile may be even better. For the best of both worlds, you’ve got to order your breakfast burrito “Christmas” style.

A large tortilla completely enfolds perfectly scrambled eggs, tender potatoes and your choice of turkey sausage or bacon. It is topped with melted Cheddar cheese and served with your choice of pinto beans or potatoes. Although Yukon Gold potatoes is an option, the pinto beans are not to be missed.

If I’m rhapsodizing too much about the Lamy Station Cafe’s breakfast burrito, it’s because it is one of the ten best of its genre I’ve had in New Mexico and I’ve had hundreds.

Traditional American breakfasts include the Conductor, two eggs any style, bacon or turkey sausage, Yukon Gold potatoes and toast and jam or a tortilla.

Hot apple crisp with cold vanilla ice cream
Hot apple crisp with cold vanilla ice cream

The Conductor is beautifully plated. The bacon is crisp and stiff not floppy and limp. The eggs are perfectly seasoned and prepared to your exacting specifications. The Yukon Gold potatoes are of a beautiful golden hue and are perfectly tender without being mushy.

There are but a few dessert selections, but those few are magnificent.

The apple crisp is served warm and topped with a scoop of cold, rich ice cream. Using apples that retain some tartness among the prominent sweetness is the secret to great apple crisp which really should derive most of its sweetness from the crumbly, crunchy and crispy crust. This is a great apple crisp!

Even better might be the Cafe’s bread pudding which tastes like really great French toast topped with a rich, sweet caramel sauce. It’s in a stellar class among bread pudding in New Mexico, a dessert Santa Fean magazine once described as “sweet heaven on a plate.”

Lamy is an idyllic and charming milieu in which to dine in one of New Mexico’s least known historical settings. The Lamy Station Cafe is a real treasure!

Lamy Station Cafe
150 Old Lamy Trail
Lamy, NM
LATEST VISIT: 12 August 2007
# OF VISITS: 1
RATING: 22
COST: $$
BEST BET: Breakfast Burrito, Hot Apple Crisp, Bread Pudding, The Conductor

About Gil Garduno

Since 2008, the tagline on Gil’s Thrilling (And Filling) Blog has invited you to “Follow the Culinary Ruminations of New Mexico’s Sesquipedalian Sybarite.” To date, nearly 1 million visitors have trusted (or at least visited) my recommendations on nearly 1,100 restaurant reviews. Please take a few minutes to tell me what you think. Whether you agree or disagree with me, I'd love to hear about it.

View all posts by Gil Garduno →

4 Comments on “Lamy Station Cafe – Lamy, New Mexico (CLOSED)”

  1. Can someone help me? I took a tourist train from Santa Fe to Lamy in April 2005. When you got to Lamy you had Bobby Flay cook for you. I can’t remember if it was him or one of the cooks that looked like him on Food network. Am I remembering right? Thanks.

  2. The Lamy Station Cafe is closed temporarily. Some codes and restrictions need to be met. The owners plan to open next spring (2012). In the meantime the “dining car crew” does host parties and special events across the street in the Legal Tender.

    Gery Aron (above) is correct. I took my girl friend to the Pink Garter (not the Pink Elephant) for dinner before my senior prom in high school in 1954. Same place, but I forgot the correct name. It is now the Legal Tender.

  3. The musum across from the Lamy Station Cafe was called The Pink Garter when we bought the Old School House (1968) down the road. It later became The Legal Tender. I don’t ever remember hearing that it was ever a Harvey House. There WAS a Fred Harvey Hotel just to the east of the station where the big trees are…I forget the name – and it was torn down during the war, I believe. The school house was built in 1927 and ceased being a school in 1964. When we bought it, we turned it into a studio for my sculptor husband, Gunther Aron and our living quarters where we lived for many happy years.

  4. Living only a few minutes away, my wife and I have enjoyed eating lunch here several times. In addition to Gil’s recommendations, we have enjoyed the green chile cheeseburger (perfect bun, very good meat and tasty but mild chile), green chile stew, ziti pasta and the grilled cheese and pulled pork sandwiches. My wife also had a pasta salad as a special one day which she said was excellent.

    There is also a nice little museum across the street in a building that was once a Harvey House, then later the Pink Elephant—where I took my girl friend to dine at high school graduation—a looooong time ago! If open, it is worth a short visit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.