The legendary James Beard Award-Nominated Barrio Cafe in Phoenix

A neighborhood should never be defined solely by grids and lines on a map or by a physical area where people live.  Nor should a neighborhood be defined by areas made homogeneous by restrictive covenants.  Neither should it be defined by brick-and-mortar landmarks.  What truly makes a neighborhood is its diverse and unique characters. Some are quirky and eccentric, some are brash and loud, others are indistinct and don’t stand out, but all are essential in weaving that beautiful neighborhood tapestry, that compendium of personalities that make up a community.

Colorful Murals Abound

The 16th Street “Barrio” neighborhood in Phoenix, Arizona is rich in both characters and character.  The latter is evident in the color wheel of unabashedly audacious and brash murals festooning the walls along the street.  It’s art with an attitude, art that inspires double-takes.  Who needs a gallery when you can drive up and down 16th Street and see better-than-museum-quality art depicting the culture and personality of the barrio: the iconic imagery of Dia De Los Muertos figures, low riders, masked luchadores, Mayan deities and so much more. 

The New Outdoor Patio

One of the most vivid threads in the rich and diverse tapestry that is the Phoenix’s 16th Street “barrio” neighborhood is Chef Silvana Salcido Esparza of the aptly named Barrio Cafe.   Arizona Highways TV believes, in fact, that “if streets were assigned mayors, Silvana would be it” for 16th Street.”  Not only is she widely considered the driving force and inspiration behind the revitalization of “Calle Diesz Y Seis,” she is its biggest star and main attraction–a James Beard “Best Chef: Southwest” Award-nominee several times and a charismatic whirling dervish who bantered easily with Food Network Star Guy Fieri on on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives.  

Mexican Themed Art: Women, Low Riders, Mayan Deities, Luchadores and More

Fittingly the tatted up “mayor of 16th Street” lovingly surveils her neighborhood from her low-to-the-ground 1950 Chevy Deluxe sporting the vanity plate “GTATTOS.”   It’s one of several vintage low riders depicted on murals in the alley behind the cafe.  Her own smiling countenance is depicted in a “Bienvenidos a Phoenix” mural in that alley.  Unfortunately during our inaugural visit, we weren’t able to meet the famous chef and heartbeat of the community.  At the time, the Chef Esparza was doting over her nephew’s newborn.  We had to settle for asking a lot of questions of a loyal waitstaff which obviously loves their boss.  Nary a disparaging word was spoken–an understatement.

Barrio Cafe’s Smoker

23 December 2020: Our server confided that during the October, 2020 visit to Phoenix by President elect Joe Biden and his running mate Kamala Harris, the former Vice President mentioned in his speech that Chef Esparza was battling a terminal disease.  Not that sarcoidosis, an incurable inflammatory disease, can slow down the irrepressible chef.  Nor did the pandemic. When COVID-19 first hit, she selflessly closed her restaurants down to feed the homeless.  In between government mandated closures and resets, she chose to give up her health insurance to keep Barrio Cafe open.  21 December 2021:  When we inquired about Chef Esparza’s health, our server shared that she has good and bad days, but is eating healthy and doing all she can to battle sarcoidosis.  Once again we didn’t get to meet her, but her spirit so fills the space that we sensed her presence throughout.

Welcome to the Barrio Cafe

Barrio Cafe is hardly “just another Mexican restaurant.”  It’s Chef Esparza’s brainchild and the wellspring of her heart.  It’s her personal declaration to the world that Mexican food can be inspired and beautiful…especially the way she prepares it.  Barrio Cafe is the culmination of lifelong dreams that began when she learned to cook with her grandmother and worked alongside her parents in the family bakeries.  In 1996, she moved to Phoenix to attend the Scottsdale Culinary Institute where she applied for and was granted an International Association of Culinary Professionals Scholarship to travel and study food.  Her chosen destination was Mexico, the land of her progenitors.

Small but Charming Dining Room

In order to stretch her funds, she chose to backpack through the Land of Montezuma instead of apprenticing in upscale restaurants across Mexico.  During her foray into urban and jungle communities, she experienced and learned to prepare foods she had never had before.  It was a life-altering experience, the impetus behind her desire not to serve the Mexican food stereotyped in Phoenix by chips and salsa, yellow cheese and (yes, Becky) chimichangas.  She wanted to introduce guests to the foods she enjoyed so much as she backpacked across Mexico.  

Horchata Served in a Mexican Coca Cola Bottle

In 2002, she and her business partner Wendy Gruber launched the Barrio Cafe, heralding an era of growth and vitality for an entire neighborhood.   Initially the response of the Phoenix dining community was less than enthusiastic.  Conditioned to have chips and salsa, beans and rice, yellow cheese and chimichangas at other restaurants across the Phoenix metropolitan area, some guests even stormed out when the aforementioned old standards weren’t available at the Barrio Cafe.  In time, the dining public…particularly the foodie community was won over by the restaurant’s more sophisticated “modern” Mexican cuisine.  

Esquites

In time, Chef Esparza spearheaded the launch of three other restaurants: Barrio Cafe at the Phoenix Sky Harbor, Barrio Cafe Gran Reserva and Barrio Urbano at the Yard.  Essentially to save her original restaurant, she shuttered the Barrio Cafe Gran Reserva in April, 2020, another casualty of the pandemic.  This particular casualty had earned a “Best of Phoenix” award in 2016 for “Best New Mexican Restaurant.  It also won “Best Upscale Mexican Restaurant” in 2017, 2018 and 2019.  It was a casualty for which Chef Esparza had been nominated for “Best Chef: Southwest” by the James Beard Foundation.

Piloncillo Carrots and Barrio Potatoes With Spicy Ketchup

When she learned about our planned trip to Phoenix, my dear friend Becky Mercuri immediately advised me not to miss the Barrio Cafe.  A former Phoenix resident herself, Becky has long been a fan of Chef Esparza and her food.  My sister Anita, the only other serious foodie in my family has also long raved about the Barrio Cafe.  Despite their high praise, we weren’t quite sure what to expect and outwardly wondered if the culinary fare’s rather steep price point was warranted.  It didn’t take long to determine Chef Esparza’s food is a bargain at any price!

21 December 2021: The Barrio Cafe is somewhat smaller than we had expected with two dining rooms bisected by a wall along with a small bar and prep area.  Only a couple of tables graced the dog-friendly patio during our inaugural visit in 2020, but a much larger patio welcomed us a year later.   While you’re perusing the menu (sans chips and salsa, thank you), enjoy the horchata, the refreshing rice beverage served in an old-fashioned Coke bottle.  The flavor of this luscious, creamy horchata has a flavor akin to a delightful blending of chocolate milk and rice pudding.

Chile Relleno En Nogada

21 December 2021: You certainly won’t miss chips and salsa with eight premium botanas (appetizers) just beckoning, any one of which is guaranteed to be wonderful.  We only got as far on the botanas menu as the esquites (grilled corn kernels, chipotle crema and aged Cotija topped with micro-greens).  We’ve had elote-based starters at many Mexican restaurants, but they all pale in comparison to Barrio Cafe’s esquites, a term which translates to Mexican street corn salad.  Who can resist scraped off-the-cob corn niblets slathered with creamy aged queso, chile flecked sauce and tangy notes of lime all served in a casserole dish?  We sure can’t.

Cochinita Pibil

21 December 2021: The “fuerte” (which translates from Spanish to strong, sharp or hard, but which signifies “entree” on a menu) section of the menu lists only seven items, but that scant number doesn’t do justice to the artistry and deliciousness of those seven.  It almost pained me not to have ordered something heretofore new to me, but it’s impossible to resist the siren’s call of chiles en nogada (poblano pepper, chicken, nuts, dried fruits, apples, pears, almond cream reduction, pomegranate seeds), a dish invented by nuns in Puebla, Mexico in 1821.  Adorned in colors of the Mexican flag–a green chile poblano bathed in a white almond cream sauce garnished with pomegranate seeds–it’s been described as “elegant and a part of our national soul” by Chef Josefina Santacruz who helms two highly regarded restaurants in Mexico City.  It may well be my very favorite Mexican dish.

23 December 2020: Any other time, I might have envied my Kim’s entree, the cochinita pibil (Barrio Cafe’s award-winning smoked 12-hour achiote-sour cream marinated pork served with corn tortillas, pickled red onions, Yucatan pico de gallo, Sangre del Diablo chile oil with sides of piloncillo carrots, quality beans, Barrio papas and spicy ketchup). Utilizing ancient Mayan traditions with European influences, Barrio Cafe’s version is the very best we’ve ever had. The citrus and achiote marinated shredded pork is wrapped in banana leaves and steamed until melt-in-your-mouth tender, imparting with it a lively aftertaste of ingredients that may elicit tears of joy (or at least a lurid swoon).

Tlayuda De Huitlacoche

23 December 2020: Chef Esparza’s peregrination throughout Mexico included time in Oaxaca where she learned the art of crafting tlayudas, Oaxacan style corn tacos.  Tlayudas will never be mistaken for those “micro tacos” you have to order by the half-dozen to get enough.  For one thing, the thick corn tortilla spends time on a griddle where it acquires a pinto pony char.  Then the tortilla is splayed out flat not molded into an envelope into which sundry ingredients are stuffed.  We ordered the tlayuda de huitlacoche, commonly known both as “Mexico’s truffle” and “corn smut.”  Huitlacoche truly does have a flavor that may be impossible to describe.  It’s unlike any other flavor, a unique musty earthiness somehow reminiscent, but wholly different than the flavors of truffles or mushrooms.  A thick layer of huitlacoche sits atop the tortilla.  Toppings include corn niblets, pico de gallo, grilled white onions and micro-greens.  Call it one of the best tacos I’ve ever had.  

21 December 2021:  When my Kim had the impertinence to ask why chips weren’t served with with our esquites, our server reminded her “we’re not like other Mexican restaurants” (my bride would have known this had she read my review).  That’s readily apparent when you study the section of the menu listing Enchiladas.  Four enchilada plates are listed: Suizas, Papa Con Calabasitas, Tacuba, Mole and Mole Calabasitas.  Though we’re proudly New Mexican, it was actually gratifying to see enchiladas not smothered in red and (or) green chile with a block of grated Cheddar melted atop.

Tacuba Enchiladas

After watching an attendant stoke the low and slow flames of El Barrio’s smoker, we knew the enchiladas of choice this visit would be the Tacuba (crema, cabrito and quesillo cheese, crispy shallots and cecina.  Cecina, a Spanish word which can translate to dry meat (as in jerky), cured meat or smoked meat can be a magnificent choice if prepared correctly.  El Barrio’s cecina may be the best we’ve ever had, a smoked flank steak rubbed in spices then finished on the grill with Sangre Del Diablo (devil’s blood) chile oil.  Quarter-inch thick slices of cecina are served atop corn tortillas engorged with cabrito (goat) and quesillo (an artisan Oaxacan cheese similar to Monterrey Jack) with crispy shallots.  Pickled red onions, Sangre de Diablo chile oil and crema are slathered on top with piloncillo carrots and Barrio papas on the side.  Not only was this a very surprisingly delicious way to enjoy enchiladas, it was further proof that enchiladas don’t need New Mexico’s sacrosanct red and (or) green.

21 December 2021: Post-prandial pleasures can be found on the menu section titled “Algo DULCE como tu” (something sweet like you).  There are only two of items on that menu, not that any more choices are needed when those options are flan and churros (cinnamon-sugar, cajeta de cobra, candied pecans).  The churros are about the size of a macuahuitl, a Mayan wooden club with embedded obsidian blades.  The ice cream is just smaller than a haystack.  Seriously, the only thing more prolific than the size of those churros is the combination of flavors.  We wanted to lick the plate so as not to miss out on any of the cajeta de cabra (goat milk caramel) which is far more rich, silky and deeply rustic tasting than conventional caramel.  The vanilla bean ice cream is a perfect foil for the delicate and decadent churros.  This is a dessert worthy of the Barrio Cafe.  

Churros–The Best Anywhere

In my estimation, the Barrio Cafe is equal to Mary & Tito’s in Albuquerque, my very favorite and highest rated restaurant in New Mexico.  As at Mary & Tito’s, a magical endorphin rush from flavors leaping upon our taste buds made them so unbelievably, deliriously happy that I swore nothing quite as good has ever crossed my lips.  Thank you, Chef Esparza.

BARRIO CAFE
2814 North 16th Street, #1205
Phoenix, Arizona
(602) 636-0240
Website | Facebook Page
LATEST VISIT: 21 December 2021
1st VISIT: 23 December 2020
# OF VISITS: 2
RATING: 27
COST: $$$ – $$$$
BEST BET: Chiles En Nogada, Cochinita Pibil, Tlayuda de Huitlacoche, Esquites, Horchata, Churros, Tacuba Enchiladas
REVIEW #1195

By Gil Garduno

Since 2008, the tagline on Gil’s Thrilling (And Filling) Blog has invited you to “Follow the Culinary Ruminations of New Mexico’s Sesquipedalian Sybarite.” To date, nearly six million visitors have trusted (or at least visited) my recommendations on more than 1,200 restaurant reviews. Please take a few minutes to tell me what you think. Whether you agree or disagree with me, I'd love to hear about it.

5 thoughts on “Barrio Cafe – Phoenix, Arizona”
    1. Gil is a gastronome, not a geographer. This is the same guy that got lost looking for Pizza Barn in Edgewood…because he narrowed his search to Moriarty!

      Tacos are really just slices of lasagna anyway, right? Canolis are just churros with more to say, or dare I say, just sweet rellenos?

      🙂

      1. Therein lies my confusion. The similarities between Mexican and Italian cuisines is eerily similar (a sentence straight from the Department of Redundancy Department). Many a time have I added red chile to spaghetti believing the chile to be marinara. Similarly, I’ve frequently confused green chile with pesto. In both cases I didn’t get what I expected, but enjoyed the results nonetheless.

  1. Thank you, Gil, for this wonderful tribute to Chef Silvana Salcido Esparza and her cuisine. (It appears that my incessant nagging has finally paid off.) I would have bet my last nickel that you’d order the Chiles En Nogada, a dish I first enjoyed in Puebla, and I’m positively green with envy that you got to savor huitlacoche, a rare treat that I haven ‘t had in nearly thirty years. Suffice it to say there isn’t anything listed on the Barrio Cafe menu, as presented by the incomparable Chef Silvana, that I wouldn’t love.

    As an aside, it irks me to death that Chef Esparza has yet to actually win a James Beard Award, an organization that appears to be in sad disarray these days. She has been nominated several times and it’s shameful that she has yet win.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.